I've made a huge mistake...

The OP of I've made a huge mistake... thread
requested its deletion, however he brought up some interesting points.

Feel free to continue discussing the issues if you like.

Stephen

it's strange.
i still think that the OP should not have the rights to delete a thread, which contains contributions of many others
Is it possible that once requested, only messages of OP are deleted while others are remained?
 
These situations can be difficult and best left to the mods.
Its unfortunate if you put a lot of effort and thought into a reply and it then disappears but that`s life,
If you only deleted the OP contributions it would leave the post without context .
I`m all too familiar with drafts being struck through .There was a time when I drafted for UK members of parliament including the PM (before age overtook me). 😀
 
The OP of I've made a huge mistake... thread
requested its deletion, however he brought up some interesting points.

Feel free to continue discussing the issues if you like.

Stephen

?!?

Surely in this day and age posting to an online forum is not without consequences. Ironic to read that others here also frequent other similar forums (and called this out) A simple name change and another forum post ... innocuous as it appears. Seems the same poster has not requested same elsewhere.

We all make mistakes (we regret) some do not have the opportunity to “request deletion” and hope it’s all blows away ...

I for one do not like to see (or) read about the mistiming of an individual misadventure.

Posters here too have been dealt an injustice.
 
Why did the original poster have buyer's remorse? What was wrong with the M-A and 50 APO?

For 10 years, the OP wanted a new Leica camera and lens. He splurged on an M-A and 50 APO, brand new.

Upon reflection, he feels the 50 APO lens is too expensive and is not the kind of lens he really wants. He really wants a lens that is more suited for portrait work.

Then, the total cost of the M-A and lens is $14,000, and he doesn't believe he can comfortably carry around such valuable photography gear.

Replies ran both ways: send the camera and lens back and get something cheaper, or, keep them both and be proud. Then there were the half-and-half replies: keep the M-A, return the lens and get a "lens of replier's choice." And a few replies that could be construed as critical of the OP and anyone who posts buyer's remorse on forums.
 
Last edited:
....Replies ran both ways: send the camera and lens back and get something cheaper, or, keep them both and be proud. Then there were the half-and-half replies: keep the M-A, return the lens and get a "lens of replier's choice." And a few replies that could be construed as critical of the OP and anyone who posts buyer's remorse on forums.

Thanks for the summary. I can guess how some of the posts probably went.😀 I think this must be the same poster who has been asking a lot of (half-informed) questions about the M-A and various lenses over on the other popular forum. I'm not very surprised by the outcome – the narrative always had a whiff of a slow motion car crash in progress.
 
I think this must be the same poster who has been asking a lot of (half-informed) questions about the M-A and various lenses over on the other popular forum. I'm not very surprised by the outcome – the narrative always had a whiff of a slow motion car crash in progress.


Yes, and yes!
 
Okay, that seems fair. People have different thresholds of what they deem 'acceptable' for expenditure and walking around. It's a matter of what you're used to, and whether you worked your way up there, or if it was a crazy anomaly. There's no such thing as a mistake unless you've spent way more than you can afford.

When I bought the M9, it was the single most expensive thing I'd ever bought, but heck, I carried it everywhere and still do, often with lenses totalling near the cost of the camera again. About a year before the M9, I bough the Canon 5D Mark II, which was a big jump in price from the sub-thousand dollar digital compacts I bought in the past. But darn, I carried that thing every day, until I caught the Leica bug.

As for a M-A and APO Summicron: a brand new M-A should be your camera for life. You should never need to buy another film camera, barring theft, accidental destruction, or a change in photographic direction. The APO Summicron is an incredible lens, but if you want a 50 for portraiture, might I suggest the gorgeous Zeiss C Sonnar 50mm f1.5 (optimized for f1.5) or the Voigtlander 50mm f1.2. Both are sharp wide open, but have a lovely 'rounded' look which is very pleasing and flattering in portraits. The Sonnar is my favourite portrait 50, moreso than the Summicron-M. Yeah, I've taken some great portraits with the Summicron, but the Sonnar is just smooth and lush with faces. You can easily sell the APO Summicron and recoup a good chunk of your money, and get a secondhand Zeiss C Sonnar, a Voigtlander 40mm Nokton and a Zeiss Distagon 35mm f1.4 with what's left. All three produce super portrait images when handled right. See relevant threads in the appropriate RFF subforums.
 
Sherlock Holmes would trace back the request for deletion to EddieJ's post....


Surely in this day and age posting to an online forum is not without consequences. Ironic to read that others here also frequent other similar forums (and called this out) A simple name change and another forum post ... innocuous as it appears. Seems the same poster has not requested same elsewhere.

We all make mistakes (we regret) some do not have the opportunity to “request deletion” and hope it’s all blows away ...

I for one do not like to see (or) read about the mistiming of an individual misadventure.

Posters here too have been dealt an injustice.
Let's see if the OP posts again, and again, asks for deletion of his post using whatever handle. I suggest 'Regret'.

Cheers, OtL
 
Back
Top Bottom