mkvrnn
Established
I recently sold both of my M3 cameras on ebay, one with a Summicron and one with Summilux lens. Both were bought by the same buyer who I assume to be Chinese. I posted them the same day to the international shipping address he supplied.
He wrote a month later to say that he had not received the Summilux camera, which seemed rather strange since they were carefully packaged in the same box!
Two weeks later he wrote to say that the shutter of the Summicron camera was very inaccurate at the slowest speeds and that he had spent £200 having it repaired. The strange thing is that the shutter on the Summilux was unreliable at low speeds, which I clearly explained in the listing. The Summicron shutter however, did sound accurate. So it sounds as though he has the two cameras confused.
He then claimed that the coating on an intermediate lens element is defective and sent me a photo in which the lens appears perfect, so I'm baffled.
Today he has claimed a partial refund of £200 through ebay. If really did spend £200 on having the shutter fixed, which I seriously doubt, why didn't he just contact me straight away about the problem and ask to return the camera?
I also sold a third camera, an M1, which the English buyer was delighted with. This whole episode has seriously put me off allowing bids from anybody from the Far East.
He wrote a month later to say that he had not received the Summilux camera, which seemed rather strange since they were carefully packaged in the same box!
Two weeks later he wrote to say that the shutter of the Summicron camera was very inaccurate at the slowest speeds and that he had spent £200 having it repaired. The strange thing is that the shutter on the Summilux was unreliable at low speeds, which I clearly explained in the listing. The Summicron shutter however, did sound accurate. So it sounds as though he has the two cameras confused.
He then claimed that the coating on an intermediate lens element is defective and sent me a photo in which the lens appears perfect, so I'm baffled.
Today he has claimed a partial refund of £200 through ebay. If really did spend £200 on having the shutter fixed, which I seriously doubt, why didn't he just contact me straight away about the problem and ask to return the camera?
I also sold a third camera, an M1, which the English buyer was delighted with. This whole episode has seriously put me off allowing bids from anybody from the Far East.
leo mm
Member
I’m sorry you had a bad experience on eBay. Over the approximately 20 years I have been using eBay I have had mostly good experiences and a few bad ones. Coincidentally the most recent bad experience, last month, was with a seller in the UK whose item I never received.
Once some time has passed and your annoyance has cooled I would suggest you reconsider whether you need to dismiss hundreds of millions of people, spanning many countries, languages and cultures (most of which are far more different from one another than, say, English vs American culture) based on a bad experience you had with one fellow in PRC.
Once some time has passed and your annoyance has cooled I would suggest you reconsider whether you need to dismiss hundreds of millions of people, spanning many countries, languages and cultures (most of which are far more different from one another than, say, English vs American culture) based on a bad experience you had with one fellow in PRC.
farlymac
PF McFarland
Yeah, that could have happened no matter where you sent it. At this point though, refund him the 200 quid, and be glad he's not going for the refund of the second camera. Cost of doing business on eBay.
PF
PF
Ko.Fe.
Lenses 35/21 Gears 46/20
Far East is too broad assumption.
I know one gear collector, photog in CA, USA who often sells to HK (only they could afford it these days
). He never told a word to have a problem.
I also sold some not expensive things to HK, no problems.
I know one gear collector, photog in CA, USA who often sells to HK (only they could afford it these days
). He never told a word to have a problem. I also sold some not expensive things to HK, no problems.
fish1991222
Established
Hi there, sorry that you had this bad experience.
I have to say some of the people from my country (China) can be very difficult to deal with. But I also agree with Leo that there are always black sheep in any countries. I believe most of Chinese buyers won't do this and there is no need to assume people should be aware of the whole "Chinese buyers".
Forget to mention, if this buyer also do this in a China online dealing platform (like Taobao), he would definitely be despised by every other Chinese.
Cheers
Fisher
I have to say some of the people from my country (China) can be very difficult to deal with. But I also agree with Leo that there are always black sheep in any countries. I believe most of Chinese buyers won't do this and there is no need to assume people should be aware of the whole "Chinese buyers".
Forget to mention, if this buyer also do this in a China online dealing platform (like Taobao), he would definitely be despised by every other Chinese.
Cheers
Fisher
wjlapier
Well-known
Far East is too broad assumption.
I know one gear collector, photog in CA, USA who often sells to HK (only they could afford it these days
I also sold some not expensive things to HK, no problems.
Never a problem selling to HK and Indonesia, and for that matter to the UK. Only once did a buyer request a small partial refund to pay for the cleaning of an element in a lens I sold to the person. His eyes apparently were better than mine. ...knock on wood...
x-ray
Veteran
Of the 3 problems Ive had selling several hundred expensive items on the bay one was a minor issue with a seller in HK and two issues in the US. The buyer in HK and New York were buyers remorse.
One thing I can say about Chinese buyers and ofcourse it's not all of them that they often try to beat me down in price. I don't mean just offer, they get insistent and rude trying to get a lower price. Ive had a couple simply not take NO for an answer. There seems to be an attitude of entitlement among some. Some accept no as an answer and others just keep on and on until Ive had to get rude. Ive never had this happen with any other group and assume it's a cultural thing. Generally I refuse to ship to China and noticed last week a person in NY that I deal with who's Chinese refused to ship to China.
One thing I can say about Chinese buyers and ofcourse it's not all of them that they often try to beat me down in price. I don't mean just offer, they get insistent and rude trying to get a lower price. Ive had a couple simply not take NO for an answer. There seems to be an attitude of entitlement among some. Some accept no as an answer and others just keep on and on until Ive had to get rude. Ive never had this happen with any other group and assume it's a cultural thing. Generally I refuse to ship to China and noticed last week a person in NY that I deal with who's Chinese refused to ship to China.
Beemermark
Veteran
I don't understand the problem you're having. EBay doesn't do "partial" refunds. If he opens a case that the subject wasn't as described EBay will have him ship it back to you. EBAY supplies the shipping label and tracks the shipment. When the shipment arrives back to you then, and only then, will they refund the purchase price by taking the money from your PayPal account.
I really doubt that he will send anything back to you.
I really doubt that he will send anything back to you.
Corran
Well-known
Yes they absolutely do.
Chuffed Cheese
Established
They allow partial refunds in the Resolution department. eBay does not provide the label for returns, that's up to the seller to provide if the case is opened as an "item Not Described Properly". If the buyer opts to return it because they just no longer want it, then they are the ones responsible to return it on their own dime.
Best to not muddy the waters with inaccurate information.
As far as you are concerned mkrvnn:
Did they actually open a case for the item or are they asking you directly for a partial refund?
grouchos_tash
Well-known
The 'partial refund' thing is a popular scam and a buyer tried it with me but I insisted they returned the item (nothing wrong with it when I got it back). Since then I've made detailed photos of everything I sell as well as recording the serial numbers as I've heard of people being sent photos of damaged cameras they've received that weren't the items they had sent.
I've also recently decided that I'm never selling a camera again, I always regret it haha!
I've also recently decided that I'm never selling a camera again, I always regret it haha!
nukecoke
⚛Yashica
"Sound accurate" is a description I dislike most and I would never use. If the buyers are mean or having OCD, then they can really pick on it.
On the other hand, I've bought "sound accurate" cameras that did not work or were way off, from eBay.
I have sold a couple of cameras that I used and serviced, all film tested. I only sell when I am 100% confident with the items I sell. You need a pair of nice wader when the water is murky. The buyers are from Italy, Portugal, Singapore, Sweden, and Turkmenistan. Decent buyers.
On the other hand, I've bought "sound accurate" cameras that did not work or were way off, from eBay.
I have sold a couple of cameras that I used and serviced, all film tested. I only sell when I am 100% confident with the items I sell. You need a pair of nice wader when the water is murky. The buyers are from Italy, Portugal, Singapore, Sweden, and Turkmenistan. Decent buyers.
nickthetasmaniac
Veteran
I don’t quite follow your point. You had a bad eBay experience with a single Chinese buyer and therefore people should beware of all Chinese buyers?
Right.
Come to think of it, I had a weird experience with a US buyer once - Beware selling to the US!
Right.
Come to think of it, I had a weird experience with a US buyer once - Beware selling to the US!
mkvrnn
Established
Sorry but I must take issue with that. I don't have facilities to measure the accuracy of a shutter, so the best I can do is judge by the sound. Any photographer quickly develops an ability to get a rough estimate of the speed of the shutter from its sound, and while I can't claim to distinguish between 1/500 and 1/1000, I can certainly judge 1 second, 1/2 second etc. In this particular case the buyer is claiming that the slowest speeds were very inaccurate, and I know for certain that they weren't. Those speeds were inaccurate on the other camera he bought from me, and I clearly said so in my listing. I think he has confused the two cameras, and I suspect deliberately in order to claim £200 from me.
So I think "sounds accurate" is an acceptable description. If the shutter didn't sound accurate or was broken, the would certainly be right to return the camera.
Any description on ebay is clearly subjective, but I believe it is the duty of the seller to provide as full, accurate and honest a description as possible. So if I think the shutter sounds inaccurate I will say so, and if it sounds accurate to me I will also say so. Similarly with the description of a lens. If I can see a defect such as a scratch, damaged coating, mistiness, fungus etc. I will say so. If can't see any defects I will say that it appears to be in good or excellent condition, although I'll avoid definitive statements such as "it is in excellent condition". Similarly I will always avoid using words such as mint or perfect. Semantics perhaps, but I think it is the seller's duty to provide as full and honest a description as possible. And in return I expect honesty from a buyer.
Lastly I genuinely apologise if my initial remarks caused any offence, or if it sounded as though I was labelling all Chinese buyers as unreliable.
enasniearth
Well-known
Really you can have this problem with any buyer , however the international shipping complicates things .
The fact that they claimed at one point that they only received one camera is suspect — this is a common scam when use it combined shipping as you do not have separate tracking numbers .
The repair -eBay and PayPal state that an item can not be returned if it’s been taken apart or repaired , I had a lens that was damaged -the seller said have it repaired and once I sent him the receipt he would do a partial refund PayPal told me not to do it in that manner as after it is repaired / sent to another address I have no recourse .
The fact that they claimed at one point that they only received one camera is suspect — this is a common scam when use it combined shipping as you do not have separate tracking numbers .
The repair -eBay and PayPal state that an item can not be returned if it’s been taken apart or repaired , I had a lens that was damaged -the seller said have it repaired and once I sent him the receipt he would do a partial refund PayPal told me not to do it in that manner as after it is repaired / sent to another address I have no recourse .
benjkim
Newbie
I've had only fantastic experiences using eBay's Global Shipping Program. Instead of shipping directly to foreign buyers, I select the option to use the Global Shipping Program and eBay forwards my package to the buyer from a Kentucky warehouse that I send the package to. I save on shipping costs and I'm supposedly insulated from a range of common problems:
In fact, I don't think I've ever heard anything back from any of the GSP buyers.
In fact, I don't think I've ever heard anything back from any of the GSP buyers.
Out to Lunch
Ventor
The ''Far East'', an archaic term dating back to the 12th Century, includes: China, Hong Kong, Macau, Japan, Mongolia, North Korea, South Korea, Taiwan, Brunei, Cambodia, East Timor, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam, and Russia.
TerryMcC
Established
IMHO I won’t buy from a seller that uses Global Shipping Program because it is so slow. It adds weeks to the delivery time.
Last edited:
I've sold for many years on ebay, with the vast majority of collector Leica gear going to HK or China. This situation is very common.
That's not to say that these methods are not used in other places, of course.
Have you called ebay? Asking for a partial refund is an acceptable negotiation, but only *before* any work is done.
In my case, I never accept partials; if the buyer isn't happy, they must return the item for a full refund. I can't count how many times after stating this, supposedly dissatisfied buyers with 'unacceptable defective items' disappeared and stopped communicating. They simply realized they were dealing with an experienced ebay seller.
Many ebay sellers of camera gear have never sold camera gear before, and they know nothing about it, and those are the sellers that are at high risk to these types of buyers.
There are other scams, such as specifically asking for shipments to be done via small flat rate box, or flat rate envelope. These are priority mail shipments, but they do not track all the way to the international destination; the tracking usually stops at Chicago, or whatever the location of exit may be. The more expensive priority mail shipments *do* track to the destination. Scammy buyers who know this will then file a claim of non-receipt, when they actually have received the shipment, however delivery is not shown on the usps.com tracking, so they will win the inevitable ebay claim.
That's not to say that these methods are not used in other places, of course.
Have you called ebay? Asking for a partial refund is an acceptable negotiation, but only *before* any work is done.
In my case, I never accept partials; if the buyer isn't happy, they must return the item for a full refund. I can't count how many times after stating this, supposedly dissatisfied buyers with 'unacceptable defective items' disappeared and stopped communicating. They simply realized they were dealing with an experienced ebay seller.
Many ebay sellers of camera gear have never sold camera gear before, and they know nothing about it, and those are the sellers that are at high risk to these types of buyers.
There are other scams, such as specifically asking for shipments to be done via small flat rate box, or flat rate envelope. These are priority mail shipments, but they do not track all the way to the international destination; the tracking usually stops at Chicago, or whatever the location of exit may be. The more expensive priority mail shipments *do* track to the destination. Scammy buyers who know this will then file a claim of non-receipt, when they actually have received the shipment, however delivery is not shown on the usps.com tracking, so they will win the inevitable ebay claim.
roscoetuff
Well-known
I've sold my used gear to dealers to avoid these issues. I've sold expensive model trains directly, and yes, some folks take advantage of you and in fact some of these are located in the US. Knowledgeable buyers familiar with the used market for a product and reasonable expectations can come together with reasonable sellers. I've found the best of these DO NOT happen on eBay. My next selling move and 1st with camera gear will be to try this forum, Photrio and some of the others. I am not greedy about price, but KEH has gotten ridiculous in some of their overly aggressive discounting of excellent, very clean gear. I've pushed back on them recently and they've revised their initial offers upward, but seriously... how much mark up do they really want?
- Status
- Not open for further replies.