60/2.4 macro for film scanning?

S

squirrel$$$bandit

Veteran
Local time
7:19 PM
Joined
Mar 8, 2008
Messages
6,249
My present film scanning setup involves using a Fuji X camera with an adapted M42 macro lens and some extension tubes. Is it worth investing in the 60/2.4 for this purpose instead? Would I need extension tubes (again) to adequately get the whole film shot into the frame? ARE there even Fuji X extension tubes??
 
Ha! My current setup works, but the lens is pretty cheap, and the autofocus Fuji would probably give me better results. I don't know how much I care, though.
 
FWIW, I use the Canon 50mm compact macro because it has zero distortion and autofocuses. I think these two features are most important for digitizing film. Feel free to have a look at my Flickr to see my results:)
 
WJJ3 said:
FWIW, I use the Canon 50mm compact macro because it has zero distortion and autofocuses. I think these two features are most important for digitizing film.
Click to expand...

Flatness of field also. That said, unless you have a way to flatten the film, it's pointless, and doing focus stacking would stretch inconvenience to the breaking point.
 
majid said:
Flatness of field also. That said, unless you have a way to flatten the film, it's pointless, and doing focus stacking would stretch inconvenience to the breaking point.
Click to expand...

Good point. I didn't consider that, but definitely should be an important factor. After messing around with trying to correct distortion from my digital P&S (and not being satisfied with my results), I was hellbent on finding the lowest distortion lens I could. So I ended up with the Canon 50mm Compact Macro, and have been very satisfied so far. Not sure if it is designed to be a 'flat field' lens, but it seemed to be the lowest distortion of the lenses I was considering.

As far as keeping the film flat, I made a carrier that sticks to the end of stacked hoods using magnets. After messing around with some other ideas like rubber banding the carrier to the end of stacked hoods, I am very satisfied with how my setup is working...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom