jsrockit
Moderator
I found Davidson's Subway book disappointing, too slick, contrived and commercial, like the filter he used to remove the sickly subway light, portraits of characters not people.
Care to explain how the book is too contrived and commercial? I think the aesthetic was the complete opposite of what was considered commercial at the time. Also, isn't thinking of the people as charecters instead of as people just your take on the book based on your experience in life? I mean, the book, dumbed down to its simplist form, is simply about the people who ride the subway at the time. I ride the subway every day (as you may as well) and you see all types of people (and yes, some are charecters). I think his book did ok to show this. It's hard to get to know people from chance encounters on a subway.
And I believe the flash had more to do with removing the flouresent subway light than a filter, but I could be wrong.