Photo_Smith
Well-known
It could be, but as per before, I have scanned a roll of this same film done at the lab w/ the same settings, w/ no magenta tinge on any of them, much less all of them. I doubt it was perfect but it was very natural/usable that time, but not this time. I don't think it's the scan.
I would still after what you've said it isn't a given that it is the developing. The said different Labs will give a different result within sensometric tolerance, its possible for lab A to be 5-10 points more magenta than lab B and still both be OK.
Without seeing the film, you'd be hard pressed to know and give my opinion but I have processed a lot of colour film (probably over 250,000).
If you can trim the magenta out in printing then the roll is normal, as colour C41 generally goes cross curve, magenta all over cast would mean low activity of Colour developer, too week too cool etc.
Like I said though expecting to match the results of your lab on auto settings on the scanner is a dubious way to judge accuracy.