Convince me to upgrade Light Room (XPro1 User)

[weather]

I recently switched over to shooting RAW files with my X pro 1 and have been enjoying the 'development' process using Lightroom 4.4RC (downloaded free of charge of course ). Mostly I use VSCO film presets and other techniques to achieve the look i want.

Here is my inquiry, for some one who is not peeping the pixels or making large prints, is Lightroom 4.4RC good enough? Should I upgrade? Why or why not?

 

[Godfrey]

I recently switched over to shooting RAW files with my X pro 1 and have been enjoying the 'development' process using Lightroom 4.4RC (downloaded free of charge of course ). Mostly I use VSCO film presets and other techniques to achieve the look i want.

Here is my inquiry, for some one who is not peeping the pixels or making large prints, is Lightroom 4.4RC good enough? Should I upgrade? Why or why not?

You will have to upgrade to the released version of 4.4 when 4.4RC stops working. Others using Fuji Xtrans sensor cameras seem to feel 4.4 is a good thing.

G

 

[macjim]

Lightroom 4.4 is the finished version of 4.4RC, so yes, it's a good idea to move over to 4.4 from the RC version — less bugs for one reason. I bought the latest plated version of Aperture 3 to see how it compares to LR4 and I'd say LR4 is the better software, just, although that could just be my lack of experience with Aperture.

 

[shanenoir]

Lightroom 4.4 is so passé! Adobe recently released the beta for Lightroom 5, may as well try it out while it is free!

http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/lightroom5/

New Features in Lightroom 5 Beta
Advanced Healing Brush – Easily remove objects and fix defects—even those with irregular shapes such as threads or lint—with a single brush stroke. Take precise control over what's being removed as you make unwanted objects just disappear.
Upright – Straighten tilted images with a single click. Upright analyzes images and detects skewed horizontal or vertical lines. You choose one of four correction methods, and Upright can even straighten images where the horizon is hidden.
Radial Gradient – Lead your viewer's eye through your images with more flexibility and control. The radial gradient tool lets you create off-center vignette effects, or multiple vignette areas within a single image.
Offline editing with Smart Previews – Easily work with images without bringing your entire library with you. Just generate smaller stand-in files called Smart Previews. Make adjustments or metadata additions to Smart Previews and your changes will be automatically applied to the full-size originals later.

 

[Ron (Netherlands)]

If you read was is been said in this link, I wouldn't be so convinced anymore:
http://steveblock.com/lightroom-and-fuji-x-trans/

btw I read this on DPReview:

"Changes to existing camera support
Lightroom 4.4 and Camera Raw 7.4 include a correction to the demosaic algorithms for Fujifilm cameras with the X-Trans sensor. This specifically impacts the following cameras:
Fujifilm X-Pro1 (*)
Fujifilm X-E1 (*)
Fujifilm X100S
Fujifilm X20
(*) Based on user feedback, the default sharpening amount applied to Fujifilm X-Pro1 and Fujifilm X-E1 raw files has been increased between Lightroom 4.4 and Camera Raw 7.4 RCs and the final Lightroom 4.4 and Camera Raw 7.4 releases."

here some tests on the same site:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/42138421

 

[Stockman]

4.4 isn't bad, its not great, but its not bad. I use it in preference to Silky because its a lot easier to use and, for what I do, I can't see a great deal of difference in the finished picture.

I have been using the LR 5 Beta recently and that is similarly not bad, for the XP1 at least, I will upgrade to it when the finished version is released.

I use a couple of other camera makes for my work and LR is spot on for the RAW files produced by those cameras, so I cling to LR in the hope that Adobe will eventually get the X Trans process right.