Daft question time.....

Paul Jenkin

Well-known
Local time
9:16 AM
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
796
I currently have an M6 'classic' non-TTL 0.72 and I really like it. Lens-wise, I have a CV 28/f1.9, Summicron-M 35/f2 and CV 75/f2.5. A nice set up. However, I just had a browse round a Leica dealer and saw an M8.

I understand that the sensor has a crop factor of 1.3 which would make my lenses 35mm, 50mm and 90mm. Questions that pop into my thick head are:

1) Will these lenses all work okay on an M8 - i.e. full functionality?
2) Do I need a filter to correct magenta cast for these lenses if all I'm shooting is to be processed as B&W?

I know there are reported issues surrounding reliability, scratches on the viewing screen, clunky shutter and the possibility of a full-frame version sometime soon (maybe, perhaps, if we're lucky.......) but I really like the look of the M8 and the photos I've seen taken by one in the shop.

Would an M8 be a good buy or would I just be waving "goodbye" to a heap of money by being seduced by the dork side?

My main tool of trade is a Nikon D300 but I won't give up film and I just love the way my Leica handles.

I'd welcome your thoughts and advice, please.

Paul.
 
All the optics will function well, and as long as you convert to B&W you can do without a filter...

I use the 28/1.9 myself - its perfect for the M8 as I see it...

The odd thing about the M8 is that when people discuss all the faults and problems on the net, there is a huge percentage who complain a lot without ever having owned one... Whereas if you as those who actually do own and use it, most are very happy with it!
 
Thanks. I'm sort of torn between getting a 300mm f2.8 (second hand) for the Nikon or 'investing' in an M8. As I already have the 70-300 VR lens and the D300 will produce superb results up to and including ISO 1600, I'm leaning towards the M8. All I have to do now is convince my missus.......!!
 
Thanks. I'm sort of torn between getting a 300mm f2.8 (second hand) for the Nikon or 'investing' in an M8. As I already have the 70-300 VR lens and the D300 will produce superb results up to and including ISO 1600, I'm leaning towards the M8. All I have to do now is convince my missus.......!!

Get the M8. You will not regret it. But buy a demo from someone good, like Camera West, and use the savings to get a 1.4 TC for your 70-200 VR. That way you will have the best of both worlds. Besides, the M8 and 3 lenses weigh less than the 300.
A M8 with a 28 over one shoulder and a D300 with a 70-200 over the other (with a TC and a 35 cron in your pockets) can cover just about any assignment. Talk about photo heaven!

Tom
 
Thanks. I'm sort of torn between getting a 300mm f2.8 (second hand) for the Nikon or 'investing' in an M8. As I already have the 70-300 VR lens and the D300 will produce superb results up to and including ISO 1600, I'm leaning towards the M8. All I have to do now is convince my missus.......!!

That's a very easy choice; buy a M8! I have both a Canon EF 300 mm 2,8 and a M8 - and the latter is the one being used. The tele has a very limited use. Mine hasn't been more than 20 meters from my car. It is like carrying around a anti tank gun. Only seldom do I find anything worthwhile to photograph with it. The ideal would be a safari on the African savanas, of cause.

You already have a fine collection of M-lenses which would do just fine on a M8. I would not bother much about the filters even when shooting colors. It is a shame not to find use for them in the digital world. Go for the M8.
 
Buy the M8, either new or used/demo, not a single problem here after a year and a half. I have a D200 and gave it to my wife. Bought a 20D to use with my R lenses, but it spends most of the time in the bag as I just hate the ergonomics of the Canon DSLRs. I'mhoping for a miracle and the new R10 at a reasonable price for my R lenses. A R digital body and the M8 would be heaven.

Gene
 
Thanks for the advice, guys!

One of the 'fears' I have is that I'll make my M6 redundant. Mind you, I should still get a reasonable price for it either as a private sale or a trade and, if I still fancy doing some film work, I could get a cheap Nikon F100 and use the Nikon lenses I've accumulated....
 
Back
Top Bottom