I have never tried Diafine, but all the comments about it do make it tempting.
So - what kind of results does it deliver compared to "common" developers (X-tol, ID11, rodinal). How are the tones? How is the grain shape/size?
I'm new to Diafine, but I have been experimenting to find its best use.
The contrast compression can be too dramatic in a bad way if your shot is of moderate contrast. With Pan F my negatives were too thin and were tonally mostly mids.
What I found exciting is using Fuji Arcos at night shot at 160 ISO under the most extreame lighting/contrast conditions. I got negatives that have a tonal range that resembles Tri-X shot at 400 or 320 in daylight and developed in ID-11, 1+1.
I have some Tri-X shot at 1250 and some HP5 shot at 800 that I will tank up later this week. Not sure how useful these speeds are for daylight, but it could be great for night shooting.
In the past, I liked shooting HP5 at 650 for the extra speed, but I used Microphen diluted 1+3 to moderate the contrast boost from the slight push. Not sure where Diafine will work for me. Trying to avoid the contrast enhancement to bring out detail.
From what I've seen on Fuji Arcos is amazing detail. It seems to help to meter deeper into the shadows for night shooting. When I bracketed, the best exposures with the most detail seemed to be twice my initial exposure, so much so that next time I will just double my meter reading and not bracket.
From what I've gleened, perhaps even 1250 is too high an ISO. Perhaps 800 or 650 will give me negatives without extra contrast with a Tri-X like midrange for shooting at night.
I will also add that in use processing is easy and fast. I mixed up 3 quarts so I can fill my large tank. Also obsessively thought about how convenient it is to be able to process HP5, Tri-X, Pan F, TXP (all shot at differant speeds, both 120, 220 and 135) in the same tank at the same time (3 minutes Part A and 3 minutes Part B). I usually mix ID-11 up 10 liters at a time because I dilute 1+1 as a one-shot. I figure Diafine will save me a lot of time and money.
Cal