ully
ully
Are Fed 5s any good?
Size and lens quality?
Thanks
Richard
Size and lens quality?
Thanks
Richard
Michael I.
Well-known
the lens that comes with it a I61 L\D which is superb.but you can mount others.
The camera itself is considered non reliable,chunky and well,ugly.
The camera itself is considered non reliable,chunky and well,ugly.
cbass
Nutmegger
The FED-5 is as good as the photographer who uses it. It's a capable if somewhat crude camera. I owned a FED-5 for a while (meterless version) but sold it. I kind of miss it, actually
.
The camera is larger than the other FEDs but still smaller than most SLRs. The Industar-61 L/D lens is very good; I use one of these lenses with my Bessa R.
The camera is larger than the other FEDs but still smaller than most SLRs. The Industar-61 L/D lens is very good; I use one of these lenses with my Bessa R.
Mark Wood
Well-known
Not wanting to veer OT but for about the same money you can get a Fed 4. Same lens but (slightly) better looking camera and almost certainly better made and more likely to work properly. I always thought of them as the Zenith E of the rangefinder world. I'm surprised that they're rarely mentioned on the forum as they (along with the Zorki 4k) were omnipresent, certainly in the UK, in the 1970s.
I used one a few weeks ago with a CV 35/1.7 lens and was very impressed with accurate exposures, beautifully consistent frame spacing (Kiev take note!) and no light leaks! Even the selenium meter was still reasonably accurate. My only criticisms would be the small, dim viewfinder and lack of strap lugs...
I used one a few weeks ago with a CV 35/1.7 lens and was very impressed with accurate exposures, beautifully consistent frame spacing (Kiev take note!) and no light leaks! Even the selenium meter was still reasonably accurate. My only criticisms would be the small, dim viewfinder and lack of strap lugs...
physiognomy
Confirmed RF addict...
If you do a search for 'Fed 5' or 'Fed 5b' you will come up with quite a few helpful threads (click inbetween the quotes for links), but here is what I think:
Great camera for the price (I got mine very cheaply with I61L/D)
They are a little rough, but reliable if working (no problem in my experience).
I don't think you can get a better camera & lens combo for the price!
Not disgustingly ugly, but not a looker either.
Handy as a take-anywhere (eg. the beach or other risky place)
Great first interchangeable lens rangefinder (CHEAP!)
Did I mention cheap?
The I61L/D is a sharp & contrasty lens.
Cheap!
-edit- I dont mean to harp on their minimal cost in any derogatory sense... they are just a bargain!
Great camera for the price (I got mine very cheaply with I61L/D)
They are a little rough, but reliable if working (no problem in my experience).
I don't think you can get a better camera & lens combo for the price!
Not disgustingly ugly, but not a looker either.
Handy as a take-anywhere (eg. the beach or other risky place)
Great first interchangeable lens rangefinder (CHEAP!)
Did I mention cheap?
The I61L/D is a sharp & contrasty lens.
Cheap!
-edit- I dont mean to harp on their minimal cost in any derogatory sense... they are just a bargain!
Last edited:
ully
ully
Fed 5
Thanks for the comments.
Thanks for the comments.
vanyagor
Established
My fed5B from 1980 is amazingly well built. I have just finished shooting my first roll through it. Will report back the results soon.
nikos
Rangefinders noob ;)
Yep mine opinion about Fed 5B is also very good. Industar is very nice lens. Also mechanic performance of my '89 Fed is very good. Timings and other mechanics are OK! Not to mention that this is a camera that i can take anywhere withought worrying about it. Mine cost me 14$ (including shipping - but i live on the end of the world ;-) )
darkkavenger
Massimiliano Mortillaro
It's a camera that works well but that's the kind of cameras that would have used the Orcs of Mordor if there were cameras in the Lord of the Rings. as said above, it's rough, crude, and not as smooth and silky compared to a Fed-3b (which for me is the best-designed of the Fed series). I've been taking some photos with a metered Fed-5 and a J-12, and got nice results.
raftman
Established
FED 5 was my first FSU camera (and 2nd rangefinder), and I've been quite impressed with it. While I've read they don't enjoy the best reputation (even by FED standards) I've found mine to be quite reliable, including the meter. As stated above, a very decent camera for the money.
xayraa33
rangefinder user and fancier
I've had several Fed 5's, although roughly built and not too pretty, they have been the least problematic of any of my fsu cameras, other than the vertical rf alignment going off the odd time.
joey
Established
Could someone comment on Fed-5's light meter please?
xayraa33
rangefinder user and fancier
joey said:Could someone comment on Fed-5's light meter please?
it is the selenium type, no great shakes.
works ok in daylight, useless in single bulb lit places.
one can use the sunny 16 rule outside, with quicker effect though.
indridi
Member
Well, I got my Fed 5, my first film camera ever, about a month ago, and have been experimenting with it since. I actually like it, but as I have nothing but my (now disfunctional) digital point-and-shoot to compare it to, you might want to take my opinion with a grain of salt.
You can take a look at my first roll with it here . Having never used a rangefinder camera before, I was pleasantly surprised to see the results (from a technical point of view, that is). The outdoor shots are metered using the on-board selenium meter, but it isn't sensitive enaugh to use in less-than-average indoor light (so I used my eyes, which don't seem to have done a better job...)
regards
Indriði
You can take a look at my first roll with it here . Having never used a rangefinder camera before, I was pleasantly surprised to see the results (from a technical point of view, that is). The outdoor shots are metered using the on-board selenium meter, but it isn't sensitive enaugh to use in less-than-average indoor light (so I used my eyes, which don't seem to have done a better job...)
regards
Indriði
joey
Established
xayraa33, thanks!
Off-topic question: I wonder what KMZ and FED are making these days? FED or KMZ could have manufactured a rangefinder with a suitable lens or two for this rangefinder. At the right price, I am sure these cameras will sell well.
Off-topic question: I wonder what KMZ and FED are making these days? FED or KMZ could have manufactured a rangefinder with a suitable lens or two for this rangefinder. At the right price, I am sure these cameras will sell well.
xayraa33
rangefinder user and fancier
I do not know about FED , but KMZ makes a line of Zenit slrs , some slr lenses, night scopes, and a line of rfs for military use and optical sights for helicopter gunships and fighter planes.
the non consumer goods are of a very high standard.
I wish this quality extended to their slrs.
yes a modern mechanical Zorki in M mount would sell very well in todays market, are you listening KMZ?
the non consumer goods are of a very high standard.
I wish this quality extended to their slrs.
yes a modern mechanical Zorki in M mount would sell very well in todays market, are you listening KMZ?
vanyagor
Established
xayraa33 said:I do not know about FED , but KMZ makes a line of Zenit slrs , some slr lenses, night scopes, and a line of rfs for military use and optical sights for helicopter gunships and fighter planes.
the non consumer goods are of a very high standard.
I wish this quality extended to their slrs.
yes a modern mechanical Zorki in M mount would sell very well in todays market, are you listening KMZ?
As far as I know KMZ stoped production of any cameras (except for spetiality cameras). FED factory is not working at all.
xayraa33
rangefinder user and fancier
the KMZ website indicates they might still be in business.
http://www.zenit-foto.ru/english/
http://www.zenit-foto.ru/english/
vanyagor
Established
xayraa33 said:the KMZ website indicates they might still be in business.
http://www.zenit-foto.ru/english/
They are. They are one of the biggest supplier ofr russian army. They do produce military and special optical equipment. They do not develop consumer cameras anymore though as far as I know.
vanyagor
Established
yep, here is the link to devolpment department of KMZ: http://www.zenit.istra.ru/qa/qa-production.html
It's in russian. Basically it says that the only cameras currently being produced are panoramic Horizont cameras. And there are no plans to produce any other cameras.
Further more it says that in 2003 they stoped developing and modernizing new cameras. And in 2005 they stopped producing them (except Horizont) and the department responsible for develoipment of phographic cameras was shut
Furthermore. November 17 2006 there was a big meeting where they have discussed how to avoid bancruptcy!
It's in russian. Basically it says that the only cameras currently being produced are panoramic Horizont cameras. And there are no plans to produce any other cameras.
Further more it says that in 2003 they stoped developing and modernizing new cameras. And in 2005 they stopped producing them (except Horizont) and the department responsible for develoipment of phographic cameras was shut
Furthermore. November 17 2006 there was a big meeting where they have discussed how to avoid bancruptcy!
Share:
-
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.