Funny quote about Cartier-Bresson

Panoramix

RF Wannabe
Local time
1:54 AM
Joined
Sep 2, 2005
Messages
19
Location
Glasgow, Scotland
Found this amusing quote about Henri Cartier-Bresson in the Economist this week:

Truman Capote described the volatile Frenchman at work in New Orleans in the late 1940s as “dancing along the pavement like a frantic dragonfly...doing his clickety-clicks with a joyous intensity and religious fervour that filled his whole being.”

No doubt this could apply to many people here...

Full article, review of biography of HCB by Pierre Assouline

http://www.economist.com/books/displayStory.cfm?story_id=4342411
 
Oops.. I'm sorry! Here's the full article:

Henri Cartier-Bresson - Cameraman

From The Economist print edition Sep 1st 2005

Henri Cartier-Bresson: A Biography
By Pierre Assouline


HENRI CARTIER-BRESSON wanted to be famous on condition that he remain unknown. That contradiction is all too apparent in Pierre Assouline's biography of the French photographer—dubbed “the eye of the century”—published in English to coincide with a retrospective of Carter-Bresson's work in Edinburgh. Mr Assouline, who edits a French literary magazine, Lire, has based his book on a series of conversations and letters exchanged with Cartier-Bresson in the decade before his death in August last year at the age of 95. The old man would not hear of a biography, while knowing that Mr Assouline would disobey.

A key to Cartier-Bresson's ambivalence lies in his family background. Born the eldest son of rich yet austere cotton-thread manufacturers from Normandy, he was brought up to believe that there was something repugnant about seeking out the limelight. Trained as a painter, he was also embarrassed by money and class, though the way he spoke, “pronouncing words delicately from the tip of his tongue”, revealed rather more about his social origins than he might have wished.

The photographer combined a restless energy with a genius for composition. Truman Capote described the volatile Frenchman at work in New Orleans in the late 1940s as “dancing along the pavement like a frantic dragonfly...doing his clickety-clicks with a joyous intensity and religious fervour that filled his whole being.” But it was only at the age of 24, after seeing a lyrical picture by Martin Munkasci, a Hungarian photographer, of some naked African boys running into Lake Tanganyika, that he saw his future: “It is the only photograph that influenced me,” he would write towards the end of his life. “There is such intensity in this image, such joie de vivre.”

Mr Assouline crams his tribute with details and stories about the photographer who was present at some of the great upheavals of the 20th century: the Spanish civil war, the liberation of Paris in 1945, the fall of the Kuomintang in China to the communists and the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi, along with his friendships, among others, with Max Ernst, Alberto Giacometti and Jean Renoir.

Mr Assouline's introduction is titled “hero and friend”, and his book suffers to a degree from an obeisance to its subject that is quite un-Anglo-Saxon. A photographer who loathed being photographed, Cartier-Bresson believed that what went on beneath the surface was nobody's business but his own. He liked to recall how he once told secrets he had never confided to anyone before to a Paris taxi driver, certain that he would never see the man again. Cartier-Bresson unveiled no such secrets to his biographer, who was happy to respect the privacy of the photographer's private life as the price he had to pay for writing about his hero. The result is polite, but too paltry to be truly pleasing.
Henri Cartier-Bresson: A Biography
By Pierre Assouline
Thames & Hudson; 386 pages; $34.95 and £20
 
Does anybody recall the essay in the old Camera Arts magazine (not the current one) by a fairly well-known novelist (whose name now escapes me) recounting how HCB basically swindled him into bankrolling and accompanying the photographer on an extended tour that was supposed to yield a text-and-picture book, then turning it into a picture-only book and leaving the writer in the lurch? Interesting detail, as well, on how HCB would send the writer ahead like a bird dog to locate suitably grotesque subjects and flush them into the photographer's camera range.

This was definitely NOT a hero-worshipping article, and I've often wished I had saved it as an antidote to the usual fawning treatments of HCB. Anyone remember the piece, or better yet the author's name?
 
Crushed, I am, JLW. But I grant your point. Always a mistake to confuse the work with the artist.
 
An artist that somehow exhibited rather odd behaviour at times. Unheard of. I like nonsacharine biographies (or attempts thereof), but superlatives of this kind (hero-worshipping, character-attacking or observations devoid of context) well, I get enough of that in the daily news. Like the French would say, pas terrible.
 
Unfortunately, we are all human and project one side to some people and the other side to others and sometimes all sides to everyone.
I doubt few people can claim being perfect, except for Mother Teresa.
 
The Economist said:
But it was only at the age of 24, after seeing a lyrical picture by Martin Munkasci, a Hungarian photographer, of some naked African boys running into Lake Tanganyika, that he saw his future: “It is the only photograph that influenced me,” he would write towards the end of his life. “There is such intensity in this image, such joie de vivre.”
Hmm, this (click) might be the photograph mentioned.
 
-------------------
Truman Capote described the volatile Frenchman at work in New Orleans in the late 1940s as “dancing along the pavement like a frantic dragonfly...doing his clickety-clicks with a joyous intensity and religious fervour that filled his whole being.”
-------------------

I once watched a short movie clip as part of a biographical HCB report and and I saw exactly what Capote describes , must have been his (grasshopper)style out on the streets.
Indoors he acted different, tried to make the camera and himself invisible somehow.

Bertram
 
H C-B non-hagiography

H C-B non-hagiography

jwl,

You may find a reference to the ill-starred American trip in the two-part, old style profile done in the New Yorker issues of 10/23/89 and 10/30/89. Here is our library database's outline of the first part:

Part I. Profiles Henri Cartier-Bresson, a photographer. Uses of a pocketknife; Comparing himself to a police or a whore; Fondness for red pepper; Buddhist view in life; Association to knife wielder Charlotte Corday.

It captures many of his idiosyncracies.
 
Back
Top Bottom