G2 Shutter Noise/Vibration

R

ruben

Guest
I have never had a G2 in my hands and am curious about its shutter noise and vibration. In order to make the answers clear I offer the following scale, which could be used for the answer or not, according to each one of you:

1-Superquiet and smooth like an Olympus RC or RD
3-Acceptably quiet and smooth like a Kiev 2a
5-SLR relatively quiet for its class like an OM2

Could you help me ?

Thanks,
Ruben
 
Third day and no Contax-G user lifts the glove. Meanwhile I gathered some internet info and it seems I understand why.
 
Im using the Hexar RF, some people said that have the same shutter that the Contax G, I dont know... The Hexar its noiser compared to the Canonet GIII 17 or the Leica M6. In the street cant listen much the sound of the shutter, but is not quiet like Rolleiflex or Olympus Xa
 
Since I own a G1 and G2 but none of the other cameras you mentioned, I can't answer the question :(

It is quieter than a Kiev4 but louder than a Contax RTS with mirror locked up. A cat hears the motorized film advance at 10 feet and no human heard it at the concerts where I shot.

BTW. the G1 filmadvance and AF is louder than that of the G2.
 
Socke said:
Since I own a G1 and G2 but none of the other cameras you mentioned, I can't answer the question :(

It is quieter than a Kiev4 ...
BTW. the G1 filmadvance and AF is louder than that of the G2.

OK, we have a start: If absolute No Noise was rated as 0, and Kiev shutter 1/50 was rated as 5, could you rate your Contax film advance and shutter ?

Thank you in advance,
Ruben
 
To my ear, the sound of the shutter becomes moot due to the motor drive and/or AF. These two sort of overshadow the shutter. It's in there if you listen for it. The motor drive and AF sound very typical, but a bit more quiet. While it can be heard, most of the time it's not really noticeable (esp at the beach, where I shoot most of the time).
 
jano said:
To my ear, the sound of the shutter becomes moot due to the motor drive and/or AF. These two sort of overshadow the shutter. It's in there if you listen for it. The motor drive and AF sound very typical, but a bit more quiet. While it can be heard, most of the time it's not really noticeable (esp at the beach, where I shoot most of the time).

Thank you Jano. But a beach or a noisy concert is not a real sound challenging situation. A real challenging situation would be inside a home around an eating table while in front of you two people are talking between themselves. Will your G focusing action suddenly draw their attention ? Would the noise draw attention within a bus, at a Coffee Bar, etc ?

Perhaps I am too demanding, if so feel free to tell me.

Thanks again,

Ruben

PS: No, I am not too demanding - an Oly RC or RD would do it at ease. (Yet I am after lens exchanging and other things)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've used the camera in such situations (personal family snaps, a couple dinner events, etc) and here's what happens: the first couple times people will notice and give you a look. Thereafter, if they see you preparing to take the photo, they have become more comfortable in front of the camera, and will probably pose. If they don't see you, they won't pose and probably won't be interrupted but by now are comfortable and won't really care.

Bottom line: it may draw attention if people aren't expecting it. If they are expecting the camera, then it won't matter at all. Under ideal circumstances, you could rent the camera, under slightly less idea circumstances you could test it out at a camera shop, and under even less ideal circumstances maybe you could find someone in your area, and under least circumstances, buy a used one with a good return policy to see how it works. *shrug*

Again, the AF and motor drive are the loud parts. It'll probably sound louder to you, since it's right next to your face, and the sound does diminish as it gets further from you. But overall the whole thing is quieter than my srt101 shutter (the only "loud" shutter I have). The camera noise is so consistent with a typical camera noise, that I think after a few shots, people will become comfortable with it.

The only thing I might say to be caustious about would be if your noise-sensitive areas are also low light. The G2 sometimes works in low light for me, sometimes not, and confirmation of focus in these situations may be tricky. Again, I think the best way to determine all this is to find a way to test drive it...

What I can do for you: try to record the sounds compared to an M2 and Zeiss Ikon and canonet ql17 gIII. I know this will be relative to the volume of your speakers and distance I hold the microphone from the camera.
 
Last edited:
Thank you Jano again for your kind attention and effort. I think you have been quite clear this time.

Cheers,

Ruben
 
quick and dirty with what I had at hand at the moment


click here for noise

And I have to correct myself the Kiev is quieter at 1/50th!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What lens on the G's?

What lens on the G's?

Socke,
thanks for posting those shutter sounds. Just curious, did the g1 and g2 have the same lens on it? I've noticed with the g1 that the focus sound is much different with the 21 than with the 45. Much less lens to travel back on forth. For what it's worth the G2 has a much better sound, the G1 is very tiny sounding, if that makes sense. Maybe I should be looking for a G2.
 
You're right, the G1 sounds different. Int htis case it was a Planar 45 on the G1 and a 35 on the G2 but focusing all my lenses sounds "rougher" on the G1 and it is slower to focus.

OTOH, my G1 is realy worn, bright marks everywhere and even the pressure plate shows some wear from the film sprocket holes. The G2 is from late 2002 and hasn't seen more than some 150 films in it.

One day I'll have no film in the G1 and then I'll pack it up and send it away to service.
 
Back
Top Bottom