monkeypainter
Established
Big black plastic framed eyeglasses are important... you can't consider yourself a serious artist without them.
Roger Hicks
Veteran
Art is what society agrees is art.
This varies from society to society (and within different strata of that society) and from time to time.
An artist is therefore someone who creates what some section of society, at a given time, agrees to call art. Is David Hamilton an artist or a pornographer? Or both?
Over the years I've been called all sorts of things, including (on occasion) artist. I'd rather someone else supplied the labels, because they don't matter very much to me. Putting food on the table matters.
Cheers,
R.
This varies from society to society (and within different strata of that society) and from time to time.
An artist is therefore someone who creates what some section of society, at a given time, agrees to call art. Is David Hamilton an artist or a pornographer? Or both?
Over the years I've been called all sorts of things, including (on occasion) artist. I'd rather someone else supplied the labels, because they don't matter very much to me. Putting food on the table matters.
Cheers,
R.
Matus
Well-known
I guess once becomes an artist only when the society (or part of it) will recognize him as such.
There are many unrecognized artist and many recognized tinkers
There are many unrecognized artist and many recognized tinkers
johannielscom
Snorting silver salts
if you create art, you're an artist.
Even if you intend to create art and nobody agrees with you, you are an artist.
Nobody agreed with Van Gogh while he was alive, he was an artist anyway.
I consider myself an artist, although nowhere as good at my art as I want to be. The series with models I shoot are entirely devised by me. Choice of film, cameras, lenses, location, lighting, time of day, accessories all are my choices. Models choice is clothing, although I advise on that as well.
Prints likewise, I decide number of prints, sizes, paper, color or B&W, etc.
If it's anything other than above, I sell images free of rights, and my name isn't printed with them.
An Artist is someone who simply makes art. It has nothing to do with money or anything else. If you get paid to do something, you are a professional in that field.
eia41
Established
What about being born with an artistic "streak" in your blood, which is nurtured at an early stage in life by members and events in your immediate environment?
Dave Wilkinson
Veteran
I once knew a man with a horse and cart - collected scrap, called himself a metallurgist! 
What about being born with an artistic "streak" in your blood, which is nurtured at an early stage in life by members and events in your immediate environment?
I don't believe in being born as anything ...
Dave Wilkinson
Veteran
not even a nudist?I don't believe in being born as anything ...
lawrence
Veteran
Although it's hard to say definitively whether not you're an artist, if any of the following apply then you probably are:
- You do "Fine Art Photography"
- You scratch words like "Hopeless" or "Lost" on you negatives
- You print using obscure processes like cyanotype or bromoil
- Your 16x20 prints have margins at least four inches wide
- You pencil edition numbers on your prints, such as '2/10'
- You're best mates with Ralph Gibson and Larry Clark
- You learned to print from Ansel Adams or Wynn Bullock
- You studied Zen with Minor White
- You swept W Eugene Smith's loft
- You changed your name by deed poll, so your intials are now HCB
- You watermark your digital work
- You filed out your negative carrier so you get a black line round your prints
- You filed out your scanner so you get a black line round your prints
- You have an agent
- You've had a show at MOMA
- You've published a monograph
- Your web site uses Flash
- You wear a cape and your address begins with "291"
- You've been arrested for taking photographs
- You only photograph at night
ampguy
Veteran
If you are either a model, or photographer on zivity.com, you are an Artist there, and get paid. You can get a free 30 day invite by sending an email to temphoto@zivity.com
filmfan
Well-known
lol this hilarious. what a question! lol
biggambi
Vivere!
If you create art, your an artist. What ever art means? If you create art and many people buy it your a financially successful artist. But, in either instance you may or may not be a good artist.
If you are wondering what the bench mark for good is: if I like it, it is good; if I do not like it, it is bad. Regardless of what the rest of the world thinks, I'll decide what speaks to me. I really don't care if that offends someone else, because they can love all the junk they want. Because, that is the nature of art!
You could just say to h*ll with me and everyone else, and just worry about creating what is true to you. You may or may not make a living at it, but it will be your vision. I think I would choose the path of indifference to others if I was you. Because, this question is an endless pit, that can take you away from what is true to you.
If you are wondering what the bench mark for good is: if I like it, it is good; if I do not like it, it is bad. Regardless of what the rest of the world thinks, I'll decide what speaks to me. I really don't care if that offends someone else, because they can love all the junk they want. Because, that is the nature of art!
You could just say to h*ll with me and everyone else, and just worry about creating what is true to you. You may or may not make a living at it, but it will be your vision. I think I would choose the path of indifference to others if I was you. Because, this question is an endless pit, that can take you away from what is true to you.
andredossantos
Well-known
This video might help clear up some of the questions in the thread 
fotofanatic
Member
All of us are artists
All of us are artists
It's just a function of finding your voice and form of expression before you croke.
All of us are artists
It's just a function of finding your voice and form of expression before you croke.
jan normandale
Film is the other way
.... My question is, how did you become an "artist?" ....
Simple. Quit your day job.
Roger Hicks
Veteran
dave lackey
Veteran
Here we go again...although this time some of the responses are more humorous than last time...
My day job is gone...what does that make me? Unemployed riff-raff, nothing more, nothing less in society's eyes.
Art? Artist?
Not elegant... but to take a line from my old motorcycling days, that just might fit here:
"If I have to explain, you wouldn't understand..."
Now, Fred has a point about the bankers...
My day job is gone...what does that make me? Unemployed riff-raff, nothing more, nothing less in society's eyes.
Art? Artist?
Not elegant... but to take a line from my old motorcycling days, that just might fit here:
"If I have to explain, you wouldn't understand..."
Now, Fred has a point about the bankers...
Last edited:
urban_alchemist
Well-known
I think that art is a synaptic process: taking an action and elevating it by denoting it a conscious, considered form. Therefore an artist is anyone who applies the above.
Then there's this guy to blow away my hypothesis
:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVqRT_kCOLI
Then there's this guy to blow away my hypothesis
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVqRT_kCOLI
jan normandale
Film is the other way
My day job is gone...what does that make me? Unemployed riff-raff, nothing more, nothing less in society's eyes.
Dave, with a 'Benz' avatar like yours, you never need worry about that public perception
Share:
-
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.