M10 DNG Problem

Logic board going bad, $1000 fix. I was told the expected lifetime of this machine is 4 years.
Too bad! Yet they are so nicely made; design, fit & finish, performance. Mine is a late-2014 27” and has had the hybrid drive fail and memory cards fail too, the current situation that has me online with the 2011 MacBook Pro now instead. A shame to think of only a 4-yr lifetime; that can't be realistic.

Godfrey, sorry to hear of the damage to your cute M-B!
 
...
Godfrey, sorry to hear of the damage to your cute M-B!

Thanks Doug. Yeah, it sucks. Three cars on the entrance ramp to the local expressway last Thursday morning. I was the guy in back. Guy in front slammed on the brakes at the last minute ... Why, I have no idea. The lane was clear for him to merge, and for both the car in front of me and myself. We were all accelerating to merge, and he just stopped.

There was simply not enough time to react and get the car stopped. The car in the middle had just barely come to a stop inches from him (I don't think she was actually fully stopped) and I wacked into her at about 10-15 mph. I hit the brakes hard as fast as I could when I saw her car's nose dip and the brake light come on, but that 30th of a second reaction time was the difference between the antilock brakes stopping the car and hitting her. Sigh. Luckily, the bus that was behind me was further back and had time to stop ... about 24 inches from my rear bumper. If he'd hit me, my car would have been a write off.

All cosmetic stuff broken. Nothing serious bent. New bumper, bumper cover, grille, headlight retaining brackets, paint, etc. A PITA, and an expensive one. But it'll be back to normal in a couple of weeks. 🙂

Best news is that no one was hurt at all.

G
 
Logic board going bad, $1000 fix. I was told the expected lifetime of this machine is 4 years.

Look up the CBC story about bogus repair from their store reps and Apple's continued rush to shut out all independent repair. Sorry but no matter how much of an Apple fan you and others are, you need to seriously research their business practices and consider if they are a company you want to support.

A great number of Apple products in the last decade have had class-action lawsuits for major engineering issues.
 
M10 DNG Problem

Seconding Godfrey, try using an external USB SD Card reader. Blower might work too.

Do not try to clean out the reader manually(eg: q-tip and isopropyl alcohol) from the outside because the contacts are fragile and easily bent.
If you are electronically inclined you could take it apart and use DeOxit to properly clean the contacts.

BTW: Next month my iMac Core2Duo will be ten years old. Maxed out the memory to 8GB (!) and upgraded to 256GB SSD years ago. 3 TB external LaCie FireWire 800 (!) drive for images and videos.
LR5.6 (!) is still chugging along despite having 180K files (!!!) in my LR catalogue.

I will replace the machine in the late summer when Apple has their annual educational discounts and free gear with purchase of new computer.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
External card reader is in the mix, equally buggy regardless of the port it is in. Hard-drives occasionally dis-mount. I'm not sure anyone knows for sure all that is going on with this thing (lots of buggy software issues as well despite multiple re-installs), but Logic Board seems a piece of it, and at this point I'm ready to just trade it in on the current version.

I'm too deep into Mac to try and switch to a PC, having never used a PC beyond the at the library and some in classrooms it is always a depth of confusion I can't get past, and I'm so sick of tech that learning something new is not in the cards.

I may try some DeOxit to tide me over, that's a good thought, tho the cards I had in the M10 and X1D yesterday worked without issue. I'm filling in at the local college this past week and this week, a former colleague is out on family leave, so will get a nice check in a few weeks. That and the trade-in will get me into a current iMac with maxed out memory and Apple Care.

I've gotten far longer out of every other machine I've owned, starting with a Powerbook Duo 210 from 1992 which still boots up and runs when plugged in. I've got two much older iMacs (a lollipop and a soapbar) which are working fine for some things, tho the browsers are too out of date to use.

This has just been a lemon ever since updating to Mojave.
 
As with all products, some fail before others. For large numbers of products the failure rate follows a Gaussian distribution. Whether they are made by Apple or one of the many PC manufactures, the Central Limit Theorem always applies because large numbers of board components are manufactured.

For every component that fails well before its mean-time-between-failure another component will not fail until well beyond the MTBF. Most components will fail. Two-thirds of all components will fail within one standard deviation of the MTBF.

No one likes to be have a failure in the skinny part of the Gaussian distribution – the 16% where the early failure rate within 2 to 3 standard deviation of the MTBF. But when a large number oc components are manufactured, this happens.

I have bought Apple computers since 1985. Not a single one has failed before the advancements in CPU/storage/memory/PS or applications made operation impractical. All this means is I was lucky and fell in between the one standard deviation failure rate.

Apple has three categories of for product support – normal, vintage and obsolete. Normal products are less than 5 years old and are handled by Apple retail stores. Vintage products are 5-7 years old. Parts and repairs are only available at Apple Service Providers in California. Obsolete products are older than 7 years. Apple provides no repair or technical support whatsoever. Here's a link that explains these policies. Of course, non-Apple vendors can provide parts and repairs.

PCs offer more repair options. For instance, HP desktop PC support is typically lasts 10 years. The large number of diverse PC suppliers means replacement boards and parts are probably unlimited.
 

Attachments

  • normal-curve.jpg
    normal-curve.jpg
    15.2 KB · Views: 0
Back
Top Bottom