I think it would be safe to say that any camera possessing a moving needle is subject to having the needle knocked off of its pivot if banged too hard or dropped. While I own and shoot a number of slrs with match needle components, as well as two C35s, and XA, Canonet 28, I've been fortunate in not having the matching needle knocked off its pivot point. Point in question, I currently own two mint Prakticas [Super 1000 TLs] with match needles, and a couple of Russian Zenit 122s and a 12XP with lighted diods, and quite frankly I think the Russian cameras with lighted diods will take a little more rough handling then the Prakticas. Other than that, I also think the Prakticas are further advanced in design, but to be fair both models take excellent pictures. If I were going to do some hiking or simply roughing it, I think I'd carry the Zenits with me rather than the E. German Prakticas. This is one reason I just bought a XA2, no needle, even though I have to give up one F stop. All this to say, I would agree that the XA2 is probably less fragile than the XA.