PEC-12 vs Edwal opinions

Takkun

Ian M.
Local time
12:06 AM
Joined
Jun 7, 2006
Messages
876
I put this in the top-level forum since I'm unsure if it's best in the chemistry or scanning sub, or even printing.

My tap water here comes from the Cedar River, and I'm told it's fairly soft. Nonetheless, I get pretty bad water spotting with home development, regardless of using photo-flo. Water filtration isn't much of an option for a number of reasons.

Since I started scanning years ago, I took to using Edwin Anti-Stat and it's been great. Then I knocked over half the bottle; boy did my carpet smell clean! A little concerning is the MSDS listing perc (the dry-cleaning chemical) as an ingredient, not to mention the cost.

I've considered switching over to PEC-12 but read conficting reports that it is either more gentle or vice versa.

Obviously I'm not looking to scrape off accumulated gunk from decades of poor storage, just a quick wipe down of spots, dust and the inevitable cat hair. Interested in what the consensus is here.
 
I've only used it for removing dust on old or poorly stored negatives and slides. It has salvaged quite a few otherwise useless negatives and slides for me. Problem with particulate in wash water is it can scratch the neg while rubbing off the dust. I put a filter in the line going to my darkroom sink.

Steve
 
Back
Top Bottom