Robert Capa wasn't Robert Capa

Status
Not open for further replies.
Unable to get assignments as the Hungarian photog Andre Friedmann, Gerda is credited with inventing Robert Capa - a famous photographer from America who COULD get war assignments!

This is one of those stories that keeps being rediscovered. I think that the first time I came across it was in a 'sixties issue of "Life". Just shows the old marketing adage of "Sell the sizzle, not the sausage" does work.

😉
 
in deed...and Gerda Pohorylle was the real name to Gerda Taro who died at the brunete battle smashed by a friendly republican tank...
There was a terrific exhibit of Gerda Taro's work at the ICP 5 years ago. She was really good, used a Rolleiflex and then a Leica and after she died quite a bit of her work was subsumed under the Capa name for commercial reasons. The catalog of the exhibit is probably still available: Gerda Taro pub. by Steidl, Gottingen ISBN 3-86521-532-1. Well worth reading.
 
There was a terrific exhibit of Gerda Taro's work at the ICP 5 years ago. She was really good, used a Rolleiflex and then a Leica and after she died quite a bit of her work was subsumed under the Capa name for commercial reasons. The catalog of the exhibit is probably still available: Gerda Taro pub. by Steidl, Gottingen ISBN 3-86521-532-1. Well worth reading.

Yes, absolutely. The softcover edition I have is ISBN 978-3-86521-945-9 and is still available in bookstores as far as I know. It contains some thirty pages of text by Irme Schaber, which is an excellent biography including information about Capa and her relationships both personal and professional with him.

Schaber wrote the definitive biography of Taro but as I recall it is only available in German and French(?).

Also in that book is ten pages or so by Richard Whelan on the topic of identifying Taro's work, which also touches on the questions of what was Capa's and what Taro's. The whole story is confused by them sharing cameras, and both using the "Capa" name for submission on occasion - plus after Taro's death, the "Capa" company continued to handle her work for a time and stamped some prints accordingly. Very interesting reading.

Whelan is known as the author of the definitive Capa biography, so between the two (Schaber and Whelan) these forty pages or so give a very good insight into the lives of both photographers. The name changes are also discussed of course. Plus, as a bonus, you get a whole book's worth of Taro photographs which are stunning.

Since it was mentioned above, Capa's Slightly Out of Focus is a very entertaining read, but caution should be used in accepting it as the definitive truth. The pocket paperback edition I have contains a foreword that points out that in the first edition, Capa wrote explicitly that parts had been fictionalized. The whole thing was really conceived as a treatment for a screenplay for a movie about his life. Much of what happened is factual I am sure, but it's definitely neither a literal autobiography nor a factual recount of events. In particular there has been a great deal of analysis and debunking of his claim to have landed with the first wave... whatever, I'm not sure it really matters now. Anyway, caveat emptor, but highly recommended as an entertaining read.

There's been so much disinformation and debate over all aspects of Capa and Taro... I really wish someone would translate the Schaber book into English. For now, the Whelan biography is probably the best source, but as I mentioned, that Taro book is an excellent resource.
 
Has anyone heard Robert Capa's radio interview? It's called "Bob Capa Tells of Photographic Experiences Abroad," broadcast on October 20, 1947 on the 8:30 am morning radio show Hi! Jinx.

The story about his name starts at 14:00, though unfortunately he doesn't go into great detail (instead wishing to plug his book which contains the full story). I recommend listening to the whole interview, as it's apparently the only extant recording of Capa's voice.

http://www.icp.org/robert-capa-100
 
Yes, I know. I suggest all read Richard Whelan's exhaustive and excellent biography of Capa/Friedmann; you will get a great profile of him, his struggles and opportunistic nature, as well as an excellent look at society in Europe in the first 45 years of the century.
 
Has anyone heard Robert Capa's radio interview? It's called "Bob Capa Tells of Photographic Experiences Abroad," broadcast on October 20, 1947 on the 8:30 am morning radio show Hi! Jinx.

The story about his name starts at 14:00, though unfortunately he doesn't go into great detail (instead wishing to plug his book which contains the full story). I recommend listening to the whole interview, as it's apparently the only extant recording of Capa's voice.

http://www.icp.org/robert-capa-100

I posted a link to that radio interview on this forum some months ago .
 
Irme Schaber wrote the definitive biography of Taro but as I recall it is only available in German and French(?).
...

There's been so much disinformation and debate over all aspects of Capa and Taro... I really wish someone would translate the Schaber book into English. For now, the Whelan biography is probably the best source, but as I mentioned, that Taro book is an excellent resource.

Yes, Schaber's book is also available in French.

There is a newer biography titled "L'ombre d'une photographe, Gerda Taro" (The shadow of a photographer,...) by François Maspero, published in 2006. There are English and Spanish editions too. This is an excellent book and a good complement to Schaber's.
 
Robert Zimmerman equals Bob Dylan. Another screwball marketing ploy. If you can't make with your real name, well, maybe you shouldn't have made it.

With all due respect, that is very small minded thinking. Many artists of Jewish descent, others as well, changed their names so their work would not be affected by prejudice.

With a little bit of research, you'd be surprise as to the number of celebrities and historical figures who changed their names. Heck, even Pope Francis changed his name - born Jorge Mario Bergoglio.
 
With all due respect, that is very small minded thinking. Many artists of Jewish descent, others as well, changed their names so their work would not be affected by prejudice.

With a little bit of research, you'd be surprise as to the number of celebrities and historical figures who changed their names. Heck, even Pope Francis changed his name - born Jorge Mario Bergoglio.

If you think I'm Jew bashing go jump. All I was saying is Caravaggio would have made it even if he didn't change his name. But maybe not Bobby Dylan nee Zimmerman.
 
I don`t think he changed his name because he didn`t want to appear jewish. It`s just Americans want to have short clear names-good marketing. The other cause of the name change might be that he was a poker addict. took those dangerous assignments to pay his game debts and didn`t want his "photographer personality" to be associated with that gambler. About the "normandy image" If that shot would not have got that melted emulsion and have looked a clear, sharp image from the beach, like numerous other photographers delivered and can be seen shot at almost the same location, it would never have got that "immortal status" I think he must credit most of that to LIFE editorial staff for seeing the impact value in that "Blurred grainy instant of History" You must realize he was in Europe, on the beach and images were sent to New York from the lab. I think he saw them first on the printed pages of Life...
I think "the Robert Capa legacy" is: To be close enough that the guy next to yo will be shot at and you will record the instant he is killed... Quite a profession...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom