SLR Magic DISCONTINUES 50/0.95 and all RF lenses

Not sure what happened there.

Leica fans don't attack other brands that make Leica M glass, say Zeiss or Voigtlander. Leica fanatics ... maybe.

On another hand, SLRMagic's fault is probably due to announcing the lens nearly a year before it was shipped. They had some high profile photographers (read: famous, not necessarily great) endorse the SLRMagic brand and especially the 50/0.95 lens early on, but then they just dropped from the radar. Also, their site was (and perhaps still is) very disorganized and lacked vital information. Reaching out to photographers and enthusiasts through forums, social media and blogs is fine, but you need to have some real, factual information on an official-looking site of some form.

It also didn't help them that they were making a very sudden change in brand strategy. Going from CCTV and Toy lenses to a $4000 lens. I can't blame people for not buying their lens, but mindlessly attacking them just because they aren't Leica seems quite immature and unnecessary.

Of course, the fact that there was inconsistency in the design, branding, and especially the quality and manufacturing was not a big aid to their reputation ... at all.
 
cant say am sorry, after reading all the bad experiences others have had with the lens and the company. IMO it was too ambitious project for a small company. they could not maintain consistency with the product, and lacked responding customer communication. getting Steve Huff raving the lens on his site was their only success with this Noktor.
 
No big loss. From what I understand there were numerous serious quality issues, issues that shouldn't crop up on a lens at that price.
 
What kind of company would generalize and blame a 'Leica community' for cancelling a product? Are you kidding?

Make a good product and everything will take care of itself. But if the person running the company is going to make such a sad excuse, I'll steer clear of whatever they are trying to sell.
 
The "made in china" stigma I guess was too much for them.

Now if they could get some "made in Japan" stickers and acquire a German brand name...
 
MikeL said:
What kind of company would generalize and blame a 'Leica community' for cancelling a product? Are you kidding?

Make a good product and everything will take care of itself. But if the person running the company is going to make such a sad excuse, I'll steer clear of whatever they are trying to sell.
Click to expand...

I hadn't read the statement from Mr. Chan until just now, exceptionally lame.
 
I think it is a pity that they could not continue. The more alternatives we have for lenses, the better it is. However, I do suspect that they tried to hard to make a unique lens. The inconsistency in quality and the rather substantial price would be a deterrent - but kudos to them for their attempt.
Making lenses is not that easy - and making 'cutting edge" lenses is even more difficult - and you need the expertise in optics, physics and mechanical engineering to survive. You also have to have a lens/optic that can hold its own against the Noctilux 50f0.5 and the Nokton 50f1.1.
 
Does anyone here have any sense of what the alleged vitriol was? it is hard for me to imagine a community of photographers spurning a good product. In fact, my sense is the opposite; that there is a hunger for quality alternatives. Mr. Kobayashi (Cosina) has certainly carved himself a niche on this value/performance axis. Any reports from the world?

Ben

[Edit to correct for Mr. Kobayashi's name -- Thanks Tom]
 
"The Leica community"?

I didn't know I was bashing that lens. All generalizations are bad™

Wish I knew what this was all about, to at least know exactly what I'm guilty of.
 
boomguy57 said:
So, they cancelled their line of lenses because their feelings got hurt on the Internet?
Click to expand...

That's how I read it, too. Apparently that forum is the Ultimate Word on what the rest of us feel like, too. Perhaps they should have expanded their horizons and get feedback from one of the other forums on the Internet. It's not like the Internet is a little town, population 523
 
I would guess that preorders just didn't amount to as much as they were wanting. If they came out at a price more equivalent to the Nokton, they would probably have seen a great deal more enthusiasm. As it is, an unproven brand with an unproven lens coming out at a new Summilux price... that's a hard position to be in without some reputation to fall back on.
 
tunalegs said:
The "made in china" stigma I guess was too much for them.

Now if they could get some "made in Japan" stickers and acquire a German brand name...
Click to expand...
I think any company new to the business is going to be met with skepticism. Cosina's marketing did a much better job of fighting that off than the company that decided to call its high-end rangefinder lens business "SLR Magic" after having only made cheap CCTV lenses.

Would you buy a new car from a company called "Bicycle Magic" that has only ever built wheelchairs?
 
richardhkirkando said:
I think any company new to the business is going to be met with skepticism. Cosina's marketing did a much better job of fighting that off than the company that decided to call its high-end rangefinder lens business "SLR Magic" after having only made cheap CCTV lenses.

Would you buy a new car from a company called "Bicycle Magic" that has only ever built wheelchairs?
Click to expand...
Nicely phrased!

Still more if they haven't even built world-class wheelchairs...

Cheers,

R.
 
Benjamin Marks said:
Does anyone here have any sense of what the alleged vitriol was? it is hard for me to imagine a community of photographers spurning a good product. In fact, my sense is the opposite; that there is a hunger for quality alternatives. Mr. Miyazaki (Cosina) has certainly carved himself a niche on this value/performance axis. Any reports from the world?

Ben
Click to expand...
Ben, just a correction. Miyazaki san operates MS Optics - another highly specialized , small run producer of optics. Cosina is run by Kobayashi san.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom