Streetshooter presets for LR vs Silverfast?

[nightfly]

Anyone have an opportunity to use the Streetshooter presets for both Lightroom and Silverfast? Just wondering if the Lightroom ones are as good as the Silverfast ones for gritty photos. The samples of the Silverfast versions look better to me. Have both LR and Silverfast but would love to keep things in Lightroom and not create a second version for Silverfast.

 

[pdh]

Don has worked hard on these over the past few months. I'd be surprised if they were not equivalently good for either platform.
Why not drop him a line and ask for some details?
I can't put my hands on his blog address and whatnot at the moment, but he's "streetshooter.us" on Flickr, and he loves to talk photography.

 

[nightfly]

More looking for subjective impressions from actual users.

Looks like they did a nice job and I think some folks on here are using them.

 

[WPalank]

Silver fast or Silver Efex Pro2?

 

[nightfly]

Sorry silverefx pro 2. Thanks for catching my error.

 

[M4streetshooter]

Thanks for the interest guys. I'll be glad to answer any questions.

If it's ok with Stephen, I'll be glad to send you a sample or two....

 

[nightfly]

Just wondering if the SilverEfx Pro 2 versions and the Lightroom versions have the same grittiness. Would prefer the Lightroom version for my workflow but if the SilverEfx version leverages some of the SilverEfx mojo to get a more gritty/grainy look, I'd buy those.

Thanks for the interest guys. I'll be glad to answer any questions.

If it's ok with Stephen, I'll be glad to send you a sample or two....