The Leica Freedom Train Story

pesphoto

Veteran
Local time
12:02 AM
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
3,894
Location
R.I.
This was sent ot me in an email by a family friend. It's a bit long but a very Interesting read.

>>> Subject: Freedom Train
>>>
>>> The Leica is the pioneer 35mm camera. From a nitpicking point of
>>> view, it wasn't the very first still camera to use 35mm movie
film,
>>> but it was the first to be widely publicized and successfully
marketed.
>>>
>>> It created the "candid camera" boom of the 1930s.
>>>
>>> It is a German product - precise, minimalist, utterly efficient
>>> Behind its worldwide acceptance as a creative tool was a
family-owned,
>>> socially oriented firm that, during the Nazi era, acted with
uncommon
>>> grace, generosity and modesty.
>>>
>>> E. Leitz Inc., designer a nd manufacturer of Germany's most famous
>>> photographic product, saved its Jews.
>>>
>>> And Ernst Leitz II, the steely eyed Protestant patriarch who headed
>>> the closely held firm as the Holocaust loomed across Europe, acted
in
>>> such a way as to earn the title, "the photography industry's
Schindler."
>>>
>>> As George Gilbert, a veteran writer on topics photographic, told
the
>>> story at last week's convention of the Leica Historical Society of
>>> America in Portland, Ore. , Leitz Inc., founded in Wetzlar in
1869,
>>> had a tradition of enlightened behavior toward its workers.
Pensions,
>>> sick leave, health insurance - all were instituted early on at
Leitz,
>>> which depended for its work force upon generations of skilled
>>> employees - many of whom were Jewish.
>>>
>>> The 'Leica Freedom Train'
>>>
>>> As soon as Adolf Hitler was named chancellor of Germany in 1933,
Ernst
>>> Leitz II began receiving frantic calls from Jewish associates,
asking
>>> for his help in getting them and their families out of the
country.
>>>
>>> As Christians, Leitz and his family were immune to Nazi Germany's
>>> Nuremberg laws, which restricted the movement of Jews and limited
>>> their professional activities.
>>>
>>> To help his Jewish workers and colleagues, Leitz quietly
established
>>> what has become known among historians of the Holocaust as "the
Leica
>>> Freedom Train," a covert means of allowing Jews to leave Germany in
>>> the guise of Leitz employe es being assigned overseas.
>>>
>>> Employees, retailers, family members, even friends of family
members
>>> were "assigned" to Leitz sales offices in France, Britain, Hong
Kong
>>> and the United States.
>>>
>>> Leitz's activities intensified after the Kristallnacht of November
>>> 1938, during which synagogues and Jewish shops were burned across
>>> Germany.
>>>
>>> Before long, German "employees" were disembarking from the ocean
liner
>>> Bremen at a New York pier and making their way to the Manhattan
office
>>> of Leitz Inc., where executives quickly found them jobs in the
>>> photographic industry.
>>>
>>> Each new arrival had around his or her ne ck the symbol of freedom
- a
>>> new Leica.
>>>
>>> The refugees were paid a stipend until they could find work. Out of
>>> this migration came designers, repair technicians, salespeople,
>>> marketers and writers for the photographic press.
>>>
>>> Keeping the story quiet
>>>
>>> The "Leica Freedom Train" was at its height in 1938 and early 1939,
>>> delivering groups of refugees to New York every few weeks. Then,
with
>>> the invasion of Poland on Sept. 1, 1939, Germany closed its
borders.
>>>
>>> By that time, hundreds of endangered Jews had escaped to America,
>>> thanks to the Leitzes' efforts.
>>>
>>> How did Ernst Leitz II and his staff get away with it?
>>>
>>> Leitz Inc. was an internationally recognized brand that reflected
>>> credit on the newly resurgent Reich. The company produced
>>> range-finders and other optical systems for the German military.
Also,
>>> the Nazi government desperately needed hard currency from abroad,
and
>>> Leitz's single biggest market for optical goods was the United
States.
>>>
>>> Even so, members of the Leitz family and firm suffered for their
good
>>> works. A top executive, Alfred Turk, was jailed for working to help
>>> Jews and freed only after the payment of a large bribe.
>>>
>>> Leitz's daughter, Elsie Kuhn-Leitz, was imprisoned by the Gestapo
af
>>> ter she was caught at the border, helping Jewish women cross into
>>> Switzerland. She eventually was freed but endured rough treatment
in
>>> the course of questioning.
>>>
>>> She also fell under suspicion when she attempted to improve the
living
>>> conditions of 700 t o 800 Ukrainian slave laborers, all of them
women,
>>> who had been assigned to work in the plant during the 1940s.
>>>
>>> (After the war, Kuhn-Leitz received numerous honors for her
>>> humanitarian efforts, among them the Officier d'honneur des Palms
>>> Academic from France in 1965 and the Aristide Briand Medal from
the
>>> European Academy in the 1970s.)
>>>
>>> Why has no one told this story until now? According to the late
>>> Norman Lipton, a freelance writer and editor, the Leitz family
wanted
>>> no publicity for its heroic efforts.
>>>
>>> Only after the last member of the Leitz family was dead did the
"Leica
>>> Freedom Train" finally come to light.
>>>
>>> It is now the subject of a book, "The Greatest Invention of the
Leitz
>>> Family: The Leica Freedom Train," by Frank Dabba Smith, a
>>> California-born rabbi currently living in England.
>>>
>>> I was certain that one and all would be interested in this historic
>>> item that was little known and should certainly be brought to
light.
>>> thank you for reading the above, and if you feel inclined as I did,
to
>>> pass it on to others, please do so. it only takes a few minutes.
 
what a bright light this story shines on the present day world.

evil has existed throughout time and will continue to do so.

throughout time, compassionate people with brave hearts have responded to the victims of evil and will continue to do so.

there will always be a better tomorrow for humankind as long as care, compassion and hope are put into practice.

thank you, paul, for sharing this.

_____________________________________

smile, breathe, relax and enjoy
_____________________________________

hasta la vista, voyez-vous plus tard, daskorava,fino al prossimo tempo, auf wiedersehen, vedali piu sucessivamente, la revedere, zaijan, and ... later y’all 😛 😀 😛

kenneth lockerman
NEVER FORGET BESLAN
www.neverforgetbeslan.com
www.neverforgetbeslan.org (under construction)
kenneth@neverforgetbeslan.com

"...patience and shuffle the cards" miguel cervantes
"nothing can be learned" herman hesse
"everybody knows everything" jack kerouac
"some memories are realities and better than anything" willa cather
" doo-wacka doo, wacka doo" roger miller
"we have met the enemy and they is us !" walt kelly (pogo)
 
Last edited:
so does anyone have the book in which this story was published (named in the other thread), and if so, does it contain any historical evidence?
 
There really is something more important in Leitz's history than the M8

There really is something more important in Leitz's history than the M8

I just received the same email, passed on to me by a friend. I found it rather amazing that so little was known of the Leitz family's heroic activities during WWII. There is some discussion of this topic in a number of places online incuding here (http://www.phsc.ca/gilbert.html) and here (http://nemeng.com/leica/005eb.shtml).

The book referenced is listed on Amazon here: http://www.amazon.com/greatest-inve...id=1166639789/ref=sr_11_1/104-7380605-7488757
but is apparently out of print.

This is a good post for keeping things in perspective as people draw down with each other over the M8, and a sobering reminder as people run to attend the Holocaust denying conference sponsored by the President of Iran. There really was a more important product than cameras for Leitz, and they didn't even want to be recognized for it.

Regards,
Ira
 
>>so does anyone have the book in which this story was published (named in the other thread), and if so, does it contain any historical evidence?<<

I don't think there's any dispute that the essential elements of the story are factual. Among other things, there has been a PBS television documentary segment on the Freedom Train (I think part of the History Detectives series).
 
Terao said:
Sounds like Leitz trying to atone for using slave labour and producing military equipment to me...
Wonder if they've paid reparations?

You should be ashamed to say this, and on this forum! 😱
I feel embarrassed...
Attached you will find the whole storry, reed before you speak.
 

Attachments

PHOTOEIL said:
reed before you speak.

Good advice Philippe, and I entirely agree.

I find many of the excesses of Leica enthusiasts rather amusing, but the cynicism of detractors is yet more misguided: I know because I was one of them. The simple fact that the Allies - specifically the French, who occupied the Rhineland - decorated Elsie Kuhn-Leitz for her wartime work should immediately remove any doubts as to the anti-nazi credentials of the Leitz family.

Incidentally, one of the documents Philippe cites mentions an (extremely favourable) British intelligence assessment of Leitz. This can be read in full here: http://www.angelfire.com/biz/Leica/page26.html

Cheers, Ian
 
markinlondon said:
Like Ian says. Take a look at this book about Elsie Kuhn-Leitz.
And, Ian was that the same British Intelligence operation that "borrowed" Leitz drawings to allow a British version, i.e. the Reid?

Well Mark, I'm no expert on the Reid (I just wish I had one!) but... I expect the answer is broadly "yes". The British would had access to the Leitz blueprints and patent documents (the latter were declared void), so "designing" it would have been pretty straightforward!

This of course made no concession to our national genius for procrastination and commercial suicide! By 1960 the Reid had become a sort of FED in reverse - a snip at just £100.12s.6d. In contrast the Leica IIIg was cheap and nasty at £88.11s!

Britain Can Make It! 😀

Cheers, Ian
 
I couldn't help laughing at this bit from the report, which somehow neatly sums up Dear Old Blighty's place in the post-war world 🙂 -

"In November 1946, the production of Leica Cameras was 1100 per month of which 89% was allocated to the American forces, 6% for French forces and 5% for German sales. A small proportion of the American 89% was available for the British forces in exchange for Rolliflex cameras"

That was good of them!

Cheers, Ian
 
Ah. more pro Leitz propoganda I see 🙂
I was talking about weapons production more than the Jewish issue, and the article states that they used slave labour. If they took steps (and got in trouble) to care a little more than was required by the regime for these slave workers then that is to be applauded but they still aren't absolved of blame.
FWIW I drive a Volkswagen 🙂
And use a Voigtlander
And own an Agfa

My point is that most of modern world industry was involved in the war in some regard, and most of them profited handsomely. As with all businesses there were different levels of care for their workers/slaves and Leitz were undoudtedly some of the better ones out there (compare with IGFarben for example...)

And conditions weren't that different in the Land of the Free in the 30s, as conditions for workers on the Hoover Dam project reveals...
 
Last edited:
Jocko said:
"In November 1946, the production of Leica Cameras was 1100 per month of which 89% was allocated to the American forces, 6% for French forces and 5% for German sales. A small proportion of the American 89% was available for the British forces in exchange for Rolliflex cameras"

Interesting information......my camera in the avatar is one of the later 1945 production IIIC`s that was sold at the US Army Px in Frankfurt in 1946
 
Why hasn't this story been told before? Because it isn't true. Or only party true.

The story has some suspicious historical holes: Jews were free to leave Germany up until 1938. At least. The exodus of jews leaving Germany for USA is a well known fact, - like Einstein and half the staff of the later Manhattan Project (the making of the atomic bomb), to mention a few examples. Most of them did so without any help from germans. Quite on the contrary. Most of them lost a lot of money when having to give away their most valuable posession; their homes. Many germans prospered from the exodus. Many jews were political refugees. not because they were jews as such, but because they were social democrats or communists. They were often smuggled out through (freedom trains!) by the help of political brothers overseas.

I can't exclude that a few within the Kuhn-Leitz family did play a humanitarian role in this inferno of cruelty that was typical of WWII Germany, but I doubt that they really stood a risk and 'fought the nazi system' with their lives. Like most soldiers, partisans and sailors did on the other side. After all, they were prominant members of the german elite, being owners of an important armament industry.

Another revealing hole is this story is the '700 - 800 slave workers' that worked for the Leitz company. How did they come about? Most likely the Leitz managment asked for them. Slave workers were not something that was forced down the weapons producers throats (read Albert Speer). Still; it could well be true that Elsie Kuhn-Leitz were arrested for 'helping jewish women' or 'trying to improve conditions for slave workers'. She could well be the only in the family who bothered. Like me, she is an european and many of us have family members who fought on both sides.

And that she received honnors after the war would not supprise me a minute. So did many with a dark past during WWII. Like Werner von Braun, Kurt Waltheim, etc.

Prove to me that there really was a 'freedom train' initiated by the Kuhn-Leitz family. I don't believe it.

If and when the Leitz company's WWII history will be researched it would reveal a much more complicated story. With family members being fore or against the nazis. It will reveal that some prominant family members were nazi party members, enthusiastic in the beginning but increasingly more doubtful, then resentfull and in the end; exhausted and bitter. Understandably.

It could well be that a few family members did heroic acts. It was a time were people got a chance to show what heroes they could be. A few took that chance. But at large, I am sure, the Leitz company, it's managment and owners, represented just another willing instrument in Hitler's armament industry.
 
Last edited:
Leitz was not the only German business to have profited from military contracts. In the field of optics, if I remember right, the famous sister ships Bismarck and Tirpitz had Zeiss rangefinders. Certainly Leitz was not the only German business to have shown humanity in Hitler's time. Thanks for the documentation, Philippe and Ian.
 
Back
Top Bottom