I had to open a Latitude map list to find out. I am in Spain and my town is at 41ºN, along the line of Barcelona.
Then it's down to environment and weather too.
Here summer noon light is harsh and high sun but fall and winter has a quite gentle lower sun. Summer can be a bit scorchingly boring, with 30º and humidity. Good time for a nap, as the better light appears around 8PM (in summer we are 2 hours forward of solar time)
There's the weather too, quite stable. I like the deep blue sky of colder days.
IMO, september had really nice light. It is also that sunset times around 8PM are favourable to see prior to dinner.
NYC is kinda cool some of the time. Generally it sucks pretty hard though. I just got back from a trip to Joshua Tree and Costa Mesa and those SoCal people have hands down the best natural light ever. No wonder everything looks so damn good out there all the time.
Turns out that NYC is just 1º further North than Barcelona in latitude, so the light arc of the sun should be quite similar and thus its seasons.
NYC does have the spectacular scenery of buildings which shape light a lot. I was there last December (talked about Cal about the weird light) and
The more we go up north, the better the light gets IMHO. Love the light in Scandinavia or Scotland...
Was in Sweden (200km south of Stockholm) late summer to fall last year and the very short, cold and clear sky days were simply beautiful. There's something very nice about sitting amidst a frozen field, at 2PM with purple hues in the sky.
And in the same Location, seeing winter lights from further north thanks to a radiation surge. Now, the dark 2-6PM times are a bit hard though.
Don't forget about this month supermoon! Night light is also very interesting and I used to walk at night with a friend without artificial light.