Re: McCurry
His portraits are pretty stock, because they focus on the people and the characters rather than style. McCurry is a "straight" photographer, so you won't see a lot of editorializing and stylish effects. You will notice with his portraits that they are impeccably arranged, beautifully lit like a classic painting, and are not smiling shiny people rather regular people...strangers that he manages to get in close enough to photograph.
When I bought
Unguarded Moments, my opinion of him changed. These are less portrait than people in environments and situations. They are impeccably framed with gorgeous colour and decisive moments in the HCB tradition.
Magnum had a blog for a while that was really great, but I think they stopped because of all the negative comments and slagging they got. I think people just get tired of seeing images in the media over-kill, and don't give these old masters a lot of respect. David Alan Harvey said "No body busts it like Steve," and he's a tremendously hard working and committed photographer who has earned his every success.
That said, it's ok not to like his work, certainly. But to dismiss it! Wow.