To canibalize or not?

rbiemer

Unabashed Amateur
Local time
10:37 AM
Joined
Sep 17, 2004
Messages
5,092
Location
Cortland, NY
I'm planning a 120 pinhole camera and as a source for some parts--film spool retaining, the wind knob etc, and the red window primarily--I have a Universal Camera Company Meteor camera.
Did a quick search and these seem to sell at around 10 or 15 USD sometimes and generally less.
So, not especially rare nor desired.

I'm not seeing any reason that I shouldn't destroy this camera in aid of my project, are there any y'all can think of?

Thinking about this has got me curious about how other folks approach similar decisions?

Rob
 
Ah yes, I go through this argument (mental argument) lots.

I was going to say "it depends on the rarity of the camera, and whether I acquired it as a parts camera". And too often, I have bought parts cameras, and end up restoring them to full function, sometimes by buying another parts camera.

This happens especially so with Leica's.

So, I think it depends on your passion. I don't restore Zorki's but read with great interest, stories from those that do.
 
I find it quite hard to steel myself to make the first cut on a perfectly good camera. I have done it twice with Nikon Fs, Once you have started there is no turning back, but have a go anyway.
 
I often say "If it's broken then go ahead and open it up"...and I have opened up things that work perfectly, going against what I have previously said...
What you're planning to do is a bit different but still involves taking something apart...something that currently works...the twist is that you have a plan for taking this item apart...to help make something else out of the parts...
I say go for it...several things may happen here...you create the new item...you learn about the donor item, it's workings and how it's made...or you fail completely and have a broken camera...either way it goes (I hope) you learn something...bottom line for me is that you learn something from this project...
Good luck and happy learning...
 
I'd do it, as others have said, good fun and good learning...and one day you'll be able to sell the remnants of the donor on Ebay, as bits of course...you'd be surprised what people will pay for a box of bits...they seem to attract more attention than a complete item.
 
Have you taken any pictures with the camera first? What they look like would be the deciding factor for me...
 
Absolutely do it.
I bought a David White stereo realist for under $50 just to cannibalize it.

I don't shoot stereo, I'm not going to shoot stereo. Don't have any interest in creating my own viewmaster images though I'm very impressed with folks who get the whole production thing down and create some great stereo images.

No, my formerly "broken" but not unrepairable stereo realist is now completely apart awaiting the grafting of a Nikon F body flange for a lens mounting place then an old broken 50mm f/1.7 Minolta lens is awaiting a donor 55, 57 or 65mm lens with 4x5 coverage. When the whole thing is done I'll have a 24x88mm panoramic image on 35mm film.

So, sacrifice away. the camera is going on to a higher purpose.

Phil Forrest
 
Rob, I can give provide some rather specific feedback about that particular camera if you like. Oddly enough, I am actually something of an aficionado of Meteors, and currently have 4 of them, including this one which as you can see I gave something of a facelift. 🙂 Despite my strange fondness for these cameras though, I have to chime in with the others and say, "cannibalize away!" They really are rather common after all, even if they aren't especially well known.

A couple questions for you. Do you have a Meteor already or just thinking about getting one? And second, were you intending to convert the Meteor itself to a pinhole camera, or just wanting to harvest some of its parts to go into something else? The reason I ask is that since the Meteor is designed for 620 film, it may not be the best choice either for a conversion or for its parts. Unfortunately it would be darned near impossible to convert it to 120, and some of the components would require extra modification to use with 120. As for the wind knob, I can tell you that they usually clean up rather well with a wire brush and sandpaper, giving you a nice satin or brushed aluminum kind of look. But you would need to modify the key for 120 film - so again, maybe it is more work than it is worth? Another thing is that like most other "lens tube" cameras, the Meteor is susceptible to light leaks between the lens tube and body - especially if you extend/retract the lens tube in bright daylight. This would probably be even more of an issue for a pinhole camera due to the longer exposures, so you would want to check for it first, and see what you can do to mitigate any leaks you found - maybe a good idea to fix the lens tube in the extended position as a starting point.

Well those are some of my initial thoughts anyway. I will be curious to hear what you end up doing for this project! 🙂

Jeff
 
Hi,

My thoughts are, in general, start with one and see how it works and what's needed. Buy a second and make one good one, then a third to try for 2 good ones out of three and then a ... Well, you know the rest.

Regards, David
 
After looking at the Meteor and reading Jeff's post, I have realized that the parts I'd hoped to take out out of it aren't really going to suit my project: the winding key is a bit small for 120 reels, the red window is not easily separated from the body and, most important, the film spool holders (which are spring loaded and look quite nice) don't quite fit 120 spools.
So, the Meteor stays on my shelf.
I had hoped to be able to use this camera mainly because I already own it and (I thought) I would only need to spend some time to scavenge the parts.
On to plan "B"!
Which will be to find a POS* 120 folder/box camera to source the parts I'll want for my project.
Which is to be a wood bodied, 6 x 12 120 film camera. Basswood for the main body and something nicer for the cover.
As I actually start, I will be taking some photos and will probably start a new thread about it.
Thanks for all your replies!
Rob


*(POS is an abbreviation for Piece Of "Something" that can't be typed on this forum 😀)
 
Back
Top Bottom