Of course, I can't speak with any direct experience, as I've shot neither. But based on what I've seen so far, I'd be inclined to keep the Nokton. The apochromatic correction would be the only benefit to the Apo-Lanthar.I'm wrestling over whether to sell my Voigtlander Nokton 50mm f/1.5 II in favor of this (I can't afford to own both). Wondering if anyone has done a comparison or has some thoughts?
I find that I mostly end up shooting the Nokton between f/2 and f/2.8, so the speed increase isn't really a factor. And I mostly shoot color film, and wonder whether colors from the APO design might be "truer." I do enjoy the portability of the Nokton, but don't mind larger lenses. Any input would be appreciated!
Stephen: to which lens selection to you set your M10P with this lens?
However, there may yet be an M10 lens profile just perfect for colors on the Apo-Lanthar.
I had no 50 APO profile in the menu
used the 2nd 50/2 profile on a guess
Of course, I can't speak with any direct experience, as I've shot neither. But based on what I've seen so far, I'd be inclined to keep the Nokton. The apochromatic correction would be the only benefit to the Apo-Lanthar.
If I didn't already own the 50mm Asph Summilux (my favorite lens) I would have either the 50mm Nokton v. II MC or the 50mm Nokton f/1.2 - even though (based on this thread alone) I can see the definite advantage to using the Apo-Lanthar as a B&W-only lens (90% of my M10-P images are converted to B&W).
However, there may yet be an M10 lens profile just perfect for colors on the Apo-Lanthar.
I turned lens coding off for my shots. If the camera or post-processing software attempts to apply corrections for chromatic aberration, I believe it will introduce color fringing.
read the FredMiranda thread on the Voigt 50/2 APO
the 50mm Asph Summilux is shockingly bad compared to the Voigt APO in terms of flare
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1676157/8#lastmessage
Yes, I see. Relative to the Apo-Lanthar, at least, which is surprisingly flare resistant. The nature of the flare on the Summilux, however, allows you to recover most of the details in post. I've never had an issue here.read the FredMiranda thread on the Voigt 50/2 APO
the 50mm Asph Summilux is shockingly bad compared to the Voigt APO in terms of flare ...
read the FredMiranda thread on the Voigt 50/2 APO
the 50mm Asph Summilux is shockingly bad compared to the Voigt APO in terms of flare
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1676157/8#lastmessage