Roger Hicks
Veteran
The 'all the grey people' quote appears to have been misunderstood by some. It was of course lifted from the Photo.net thread about what a terrible load of grey conformists we are in this forum: I meant it, of course, entirely ironically, because I had received so many splendid replies. I apologize from the botom of my heart to anyone who thought otherwise.
As for JLW's point that an economy has to produce a lot of surplus in order for people to live outside the realm of getting and spending, this is something I have thought long and hard about. It comes quite close to Marx's theory of superabundance.
To a considerable extent, of course JLW is right. But my own suspicion is that we -- that is, rich western nations -- reached that point quite a long time ago: possibly as early as the 1950s in the United States, probably the 1960s in Britain. Although it is plainly mpossible for everyone to drop out of the rat race, I really do believe that ten times as many people could do what they wanted, if they were brave enough and if they had different priorities.
I fully take the point that dumb luck plays a very large part in anyone's success or failure, but equally, I'd not rank it as high as 95 per cent except perhaps as a function of where and when you are born. My lifesyle may sound idyllic but it's very poorly paid and I just don't buy a lot of the things that many take for granted: expensive clothes, new cars, and so forth. Fortunately my wife fees exactly the same way, though I think she bought some make-up in 2000 or 2001.
But a lot of people prefer security and a guranteed income. The best of luck to them. I was thinking more of those who think that it's impossible to do what several people on this forum have indeed done. I have long been a firm believer in "be careful what you pray for, for you will surely get it."
Cheers,
Roger
As for JLW's point that an economy has to produce a lot of surplus in order for people to live outside the realm of getting and spending, this is something I have thought long and hard about. It comes quite close to Marx's theory of superabundance.
To a considerable extent, of course JLW is right. But my own suspicion is that we -- that is, rich western nations -- reached that point quite a long time ago: possibly as early as the 1950s in the United States, probably the 1960s in Britain. Although it is plainly mpossible for everyone to drop out of the rat race, I really do believe that ten times as many people could do what they wanted, if they were brave enough and if they had different priorities.
I fully take the point that dumb luck plays a very large part in anyone's success or failure, but equally, I'd not rank it as high as 95 per cent except perhaps as a function of where and when you are born. My lifesyle may sound idyllic but it's very poorly paid and I just don't buy a lot of the things that many take for granted: expensive clothes, new cars, and so forth. Fortunately my wife fees exactly the same way, though I think she bought some make-up in 2000 or 2001.
But a lot of people prefer security and a guranteed income. The best of luck to them. I was thinking more of those who think that it's impossible to do what several people on this forum have indeed done. I have long been a firm believer in "be careful what you pray for, for you will surely get it."
Cheers,
Roger