bmattock
Veteran
I'm starting a new thread based on the direction it was headed, hope no one minds. We were discussing the relative merits of a particular B&W film, and got a bit side-tracked on who makes what. So I thought that was worthy of it's own thread and here it is:
Re: Tura - really? Aw, what a shame! I keep thinking that there are more B&W film manufacturers than there really are. Here's what I come up with, in no particular order:
1) Kodak
2) Ilford
3) Agfa (Tura, Orwo, others)
4) Fuji
5) Efke (Adox)
6) Foma
7) Forte
8) Lucky
9) Svema
10) Tasma
Am I missing anyone? I mean, Gigabit, Bergger, Paterson, Rollei, Orwo, and others are just repackagers, yes? I'd count them if they had an emulsion made to their specifications and only sold by them, but I think they just buy / relabel other brands, if I'm not mistaken. Konica-Minolta makes C41 and B&W C41, but no actual B&W, same for Ferrania (Solaris / 3M / Imation in the USA). Mitsubishi supposedly makes color film in the USA, but I haven't seen any of it. I am told that there is another film manufacturer inside China other than Lucky, but I haven't seen anything else about them if that is true.
Now, if we can come with a corrected list of manufacturers of B&W film stock, let's cross-reference that with who repackages what, and if we're feeling really ambitious, the various emulsions sold in various formats from each manufacturer.
If we come up with an up-to-date list that everybody agrees on, I'll make a webpage out of it and try to keep it updated. If anyone thinks that would be worthwhile, that is.
And yes, I know about the Massive Dev Chart and the ACE webpages - useful references, but not focused directly on this. I was thinking more along the lines of the perennial questions - what B&W make/model should I use for portrait/outdoors/indoors/studio/etc/etc? Not that we'd all agree, but some basic information minus the manufacturer's hype would be nice.
Best Regards,
Bill Mattocks
Roman said:Bill,
Tura films are just respooled Agfa films! I heard rumors, though, that they are closing down their spooling plant.
'alex-photo' occasionally sells Svema film, http://www.retrophotographic.com/ sells Tasma films (they are located in the UK, though).
Roman
Re: Tura - really? Aw, what a shame! I keep thinking that there are more B&W film manufacturers than there really are. Here's what I come up with, in no particular order:
1) Kodak
2) Ilford
3) Agfa (Tura, Orwo, others)
4) Fuji
5) Efke (Adox)
6) Foma
7) Forte
8) Lucky
9) Svema
10) Tasma
Am I missing anyone? I mean, Gigabit, Bergger, Paterson, Rollei, Orwo, and others are just repackagers, yes? I'd count them if they had an emulsion made to their specifications and only sold by them, but I think they just buy / relabel other brands, if I'm not mistaken. Konica-Minolta makes C41 and B&W C41, but no actual B&W, same for Ferrania (Solaris / 3M / Imation in the USA). Mitsubishi supposedly makes color film in the USA, but I haven't seen any of it. I am told that there is another film manufacturer inside China other than Lucky, but I haven't seen anything else about them if that is true.
Now, if we can come with a corrected list of manufacturers of B&W film stock, let's cross-reference that with who repackages what, and if we're feeling really ambitious, the various emulsions sold in various formats from each manufacturer.
If we come up with an up-to-date list that everybody agrees on, I'll make a webpage out of it and try to keep it updated. If anyone thinks that would be worthwhile, that is.
And yes, I know about the Massive Dev Chart and the ACE webpages - useful references, but not focused directly on this. I was thinking more along the lines of the perennial questions - what B&W make/model should I use for portrait/outdoors/indoors/studio/etc/etc? Not that we'd all agree, but some basic information minus the manufacturer's hype would be nice.
Best Regards,
Bill Mattocks