wgerrard
Veteran
what you want insurers to give you your money back if you've had no claims? 😕
Well, if they did they'd still get to keep the profit they'd made from other people's money.
More seriously, I'm just highlighting that the foundation of insurance is the principle that spreading risk among many insureds -- few of whom will ever file a claim -- allows coverage to be affordable to those insureds while also allowing the insurance company to retain a profit. Insurance is very definitely not based on a bet between a company and a single insured. It's impossible to know if I will wreck my car tomorrow. But, it's not difficult to produce an accurate estimate of the number of crashes that will occur among, say, a population of 10 million drivers.
Insurance companies know more about this than anyone else and have staffs of statisticians and math wonks running the numbers. You can be sure that any insurance company will stop selling a particular line if they believe claims will rise to a level threatening profitability.
What I and others object to is the practice of actively looking for reasons to nullify insurance after an otherwise legitimate claim has been filed. If I buy a policy, pay premium for years, if not decades, and then file a claim, the insurance company should not be allowed to cancel me based on some hitherto undiscovered fault. The law should restrict such cancellation to a short time period after policy activation.