canon 35/2.8 chrome vs 35/2.8 black & chrome

[back alley]

has anyone had the opportunity to own/try these 2 lenses side by side?

looking at the canon museum site it appears that they are the same lens optically.
the black & chrome version is lighter in weight and has a 40mm filter size while the chrome has a 34 filter size.

i'm most interested in the contrast levels and if pics from these 2 look the same.

any info appreciated.

joe

 

[bmattock]

Joe,

Sorry, I only have the black one. You can borrow it if you like though.

Best Regards,

Bill Mattocks

 

[back alley]

wow, that's very generous of you bill.

i need to think about that one.

joe

 

[rover]

You will have to provide us with some feedback Joe of your comparison.

 

[back alley]

i'm thinking maybe of trading the chrome for a black & chrome.

but maybe that's just dumb...

joe

 

[FrankS]

If there is any difference, then the newer lens may be slightly sharper and with a bit more contrast (improved coating).

 

[bmattock]

Well, try 'em side by side and see whatcha think, Joe. I can have it in the mail to you early next week. Of course, you may not get it until Christmas...dang it.

Best Regards,

Bill Mattocks

 

[back alley]

ok, i'll take you up on your very generous offer bill.

do you need my address or do you still have it?

joe

 

[bmattock]

ok, i'll take you up on your very generous offer bill.

do you need my address or do you still have it?

joe

I doubt if I have it anymore, Joe, but you have my email.

Best Regards,

Bill Mattocks

 

[back alley]

i'll p.m. you now.

joe