amateriat said:
Having both worked on live recordings and worked with various grades of audio gear (high- and low-end), I have to seriously disagree with you on that one. There's a difference that doesn't require a golden ear to discern (a tin ear is another matter). Whether someone cares at all about the difference, large or small, is another matter altogether. Most don't. MP3 might be the best thing a lot of people have ever heard. Then, too, a color Xerox pinned to someone's bulltin board may be a perfect photographic representation of a person or event, at least from a distance.
- Barrett
OK stream of consciousness post
Once again just like cameras, its about what your preference is ... When I was in college, there was a high end Stereo dealer across commonwealth ave and one day I went in bought a pair of Grado SR60s for my walk around Campus headphones, the owners would allow me to listen to all the high end audio equipment, brand-new (then) SACD, Vinyl, DVD-Audio, on Legacy Speakers or B&W speakers, even the Wilson Audio Pups made an appearance ... I would go back to my dorm where I had an old Sony 2-channel amp hooked to my laptop, a old turn table, to a pair of aging Advent "Small" Speakers (small was just the name, they were actually big by today's standards). I would listen to my CDs, Vinyl, MP3s and I could always tell the difference
Now, I usually do my listening in the car and at work via my Sansa MP3 player with Rhapsody files (which are even more compressed than MP3s), I can tell the difference but they sound pretty darn good even on my Grado headphones or my Tivoli PAL at work. Do they sound like a Electrostatic speakers attached to Monoblocks on high weight vinyl spinning on a Sota turntable? Absolutely not ... but does it allow me to enjoy my music everywhere I would like to be with litteraly thousands of titles, genres, and albums at my disposle? Hell yeah
And yet I still do take my weekends to spin one of my various favorite jazz albums, on my old turntable (with Grado Black cartridge), hooked to my wharfedale towers (I won these in a contest, lucky me), and enjoy what sounds like Art Blakey banging his drums in my own living quarters.
I can Appreciate it, but I can appreciate the decent quality of sound that comes out of my little Sansa player as well.
Same thing when it comes to the difference between a Holga and a Hasselblad
I can appreciate both as they have qualities the others don't ... I can still appreciate the pictures I took in highschool with my Kodak APS camera despite their low quality and my obvious point and shoot nature (didn't have a huge interest in photography as I do now), then I can appreciate the real keepers I can get now with more sophisticated/perhaps better equipment.
Sometimes you can enjoy both a movie like American Pie and a Masterpiece like Godfather.... sometimes you don't want to see either
I don't think anyone needs to sit any determine the validity of the existence of one over the other.
whew ... that was long