Digital or Film? Post Yours Let's Guess

[350D_user]

If that's digital, you have to teach me how you do that.

I said it was easy.

PM sent.

 

[350D_user]

iml - First, film, details in the shadow. Second one, digital, though cannot be 100% certain on this.
Fishric - First, digital, blown highlights in the sky. Second, film, tonal range.
Kin Lau - First, digital, desaturated colour photo. Second, digital, possible chromatic abberations on the lower edge of the branch.

 

[nksyoon]

No exif peeking!

Large: http://farm1.static.flickr.com/178/436831499_a9dcb39d21_o.jpg

Large: http://farm1.static.flickr.com/151/436830316_f82a420c89_o.jpg

Large: http://farm1.static.flickr.com/109/254357479_2458106f60_o.jpg

 

[Kin Lau]

Kin Lau - First, digital, desaturated colour photo. Second, digital, possible chromatic abberations on the lower edge of the branch.

You're 1/2 right.... I won't tell you which half yet

There's no CA in the 2nd pic.

 

[iml]

iml - First, film, details in the shadow. Second one, digital, though cannot be 100% certain on this.

Not quite

First one is digital (Ricoh GR-D), the second is film (Leica M6/Pan F). I must admit that's the most digital looking film shot I can find.

On the whole I have no trouble preferring prints I make from film, even though I doubt I can reliably spot whether something is digital or film, if that makes any sense.

Ian

 

[shadowfox]

Digital, courtesy of blown highlights.

Only one of them is digital, the other one is T-MAX 100.

 

[Gabriel M.A.]

What's your guess?

OK, I'll bite.
The first one is film, the second is digital. I'll even go one step further and say that the first one was taken with a Nikon lens. Don't know which, but looks like a Nikon lens.

 

[Gabriel M.A.]

No exif peeking!

These are really tough; and I say that, because they all look digital, but since the "game" is supposed to have you show at least one film and one digital, then I must assume that one of them is film. If one of them is film, it's the last one. These are the toughest ones I've ever had to pick the film shot from.

 

[Kin Lau]

I'll even go one step further and say that the first one was taken with a Nikon lens. Don't know which, but looks like a Nikon lens.

Ha.... Sigma 400/5.6

 

[nksyoon]

These are really tough; and I say that, because they all look digital, but since the "game" is supposed to have you show at least one film and one digital, then I must assume that one of them is film. If one of them is film, it's the last one. These are the toughest ones I've ever had to pick the film shot from.

The first 2 are your former Summicron 90 on Canon 5D, the last is CV 28/1.9 on Kodachrome 64.

 

[Kin Lau]

My 1st shot is APX100, Canon EOS, Sigma 400/5.6
2nd shot is 20D, Sigma 120-300/2.8