Help With Contax Lens: 100mm-135mm

bwcolor

Veteran
Local time
10:45 PM
Joined
Jul 26, 2009
Messages
2,348
Location
S.F. Bay Area
I've been looking at the various lenses in this group and other than the 100mm S-Planar f/4, they all look great on paper.

Anyone have input regarding the C/Y versions:

100mm Planar f/2.0
100mm Makro-Planar f/2.8
135mm Sonnar f/2.8

Thanks..
 
I've been looking at the various lenses in this group and other than the 100mm S-Planar f/4, they all look great on paper.

Anyone have input regarding the C/Y versions:

100mm Planar f/2.0
100mm Makro-Planar f/2.8
135mm Sonnar f/2.8

Thanks..

Staggeringly gorgeous lens. The only reason we don't have one is that we couldn't afford it even with the discount, so we had to give it back.

Cheers,

R.
 
I can see what is going to happen. All of these lenses are very good. Your reviews first got me looking in this direction. Since you have all of the lenses, which one do you use the most? Perhaps, that will be the only real way to find out which is the one lens to buy.
 
Staggeringly gorgeous lens. The only reason we don't have one is that we couldn't afford it even with the discount, so we had to give it back.

Cheers,

R.

I gather that you no longer use the system. I say this because the used prices are much more reasonable. At least for the Makro and the 135mm.
 
I have the P 100 f2 and it is a stunning lens. Very very sharp. In it's day one of the very best lenses available. It still has to be one.
 
I can see what is going to happen. All of these lenses are very good. Your reviews first got me looking in this direction. Since you have all of the lenses, which one do you use the most? Perhaps, that will be the only real way to find out which is the one lens to buy.

A very difficult question to answer. In Rollei days I like the 135/2.8 HFT Sonnar very much, and Rollei did not offer others. However, in Contax era there are 100/2, 100/2.8 Macro, 135/2.8 and 135/2. Due to personal preference I still like focal length 135mm a lot. 100/2.8 macro is heavy but u have the advantage of getting into 1:1 macro mode anytime. The 135/2.8 now can get used at very reasonable price.
 
You own almost every Leica ever made and you can't afford C/Y Zeiss lens?

Well, hardly. IIIa-M2-M4P-MP-M8-M9. I've had A, II, III, IIIb, IIIc, IIIf, IIIg and M3 as well, but they're all long gone.

We had an Aria and an AX on a long-ish loan from the UK importers for review, with 35/1.4, 35/2.8 shift and 100/2.8 Makro. That was maybe 15 years ago when I still had a mortgage, etc. Remember what the new prices were like!

Now, bear in mind that at the same time I had a Nikon system (most of which I still have) with half a dozen bodies and 28-35-50-90-135-200-300-600 (not all Nikon, but some focal lengths were doubled up). Yes, the 35 shift was better than the Nikkor; the 100/2.8 was better than the 90/2.5 Vivitar Series 1 (and that's saying something!); and the only other 35/1.4 I had was on my Leicas, which is a better place for a 35/1.4 than an SLR as far as I am concerned. I also had, for the Leicas, 15-21-28-35-50-65-90-135.

Obviously I was offered a significant discount when the time came to return the gear, but even at that, it didn't strike me as a brilliant idea to buy into a third, non-compatible system, so I didn't. If we'd been able to get it for even less, Frances was considering it for her own system. As it was, we decided we couldn't afford it, and besides, it would then have meant travelling with three 35mm systems, none of them mutually compatible. As most of our photography is done while travelling, you'll see why we turned it down.

In 35mm, Frances now uses mostly Leica, Voigtländer and Zeiss Ikon. Her favourite lenses are mostly different from mine so with (say) 3 lenses each we have 5 focal lengths, 18-35-50-75-135, though I sometimes carry the 15 anyway (why not, it's so small) and she sometimes picks up a 90 for an 18-50-90 outfit.

Cheers,

R.
 
Last edited:
Make sense! Now I have to wonder why on earth I have almost every brand except Zeiss C/Y. May be sell off some stuff and get the lens to try out.
Dear Hans,

Because it's hard to resist 'bargains', but they're insidious for two reasons.

The first is that money spent on 'bargains' is money not available to spend on stuff you really want but 'can't afford' (and the reason you 'can't afford' it is that you've already blown the money on stuff you 'can afford').

The second is that you end up with those damn' silly threads asking which three of your seven incompatible systems you should take to Albania or Burkina Faso.

Incompatible systems make sense if they have their own real strengths -- ONE SLR system and ONE rangefinder system -- or for different formats, though even then, I use many of the same lenses on 4x5, 6x7 and 8x10. But nowadays, I buy 35mm cameras outside Nikon (fit) and Leica (fit) only if they're 'bargains' and if I can make money out of a 'Classic and Collector' piece or for sentimental reasons (hence my Pentax SV, because an SV was my first decent camera).

In fact, the last decent 35mm camera I acquired, a Contaflex Super BC with Tessar, I was given -- and one of my SVs was a present too.

Cheers,

R.
 
I have the 135 2.8 Sonnar which I love. Well I did until it got fungus through keeping it in a contax leather pouch. If you buy a C/Y lens and it has a leather pouch then bin the pouch. Fungus feeds of the protein in leather.
 
I must admit that my Zeiss 100-300mm zoom is so very good that making the jump to a fixed focal lens is of limited value. Even the Makro's MTF really only offers about a one+ stop advantage of this zoom, but of course it offers slightly lighter weight and Mak(c)ro.

Zoom MTF

Makro MTF
 
Thanks for the feedback. I just lost a Buy it Now from one of my favorite vendors in Japan. Two seconds later a new/old stock 100mm Makro Planar came up. We will see when it arrives, but this concludes my Contax system. Now, to work a lot to pay for it.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the feedback. I just lost a Buy it Now from one of my favorite vendors in Japan. Two seconds laster a new/old stock 100mm Makro Planar came up. We will see when it arrives, but this concludes my Contax system. Now, to work a lot to pay for it.

Congrats on your 100 macro planar. Dun think u can go wrong with any
Zeiss actually, but being a long time Zeiss supporter I am definitely bias hahaha!
 
Back
Top Bottom