This thread has confirmed to me to go ahead and get an M8. The opinions are mixed, and there is no absolute truth on what is really the best for the money. Luck plays a role here, and I have been a rather lucky man in my life.
This really sums it up as there is no hard facts just different experiences from users ...... here is part of an email I received from Leica in regards to some questions when getting my camera repaired ... I posted this over at LUF awhile back ...
Original Thread
http://www.l-camera-forum.com/leica-forum/leica-m8-forum/184736-m8-shutter-just-failed.html#post1728491
I had the shutter in my M8 fail recently and had some similar questions and concerns before having it repaired .Here are some answers to those questions I got via email .......
The Email :
Below are a few questions that I have been trying to get answered for the past 3 months . It was never about not wanting to get he camera repaired , just wanted to make the right decision as to which way I should go .... repair the shutter or upgrade and why one over the other .
1 ) Is there a direct correlation between shutter failures and a particular setting on the camera ?
No, there is no direct correlation between shutter failures or any particular setting on the camera.
2) What is likely to cause the shutter to fail and is there something the user can do that is preventive in use that would make this less likely to occur or is it completely random ?
No, there is nothing that the user can do to prevent a shutter failure, this happens randomly sometimes.
3)Is the shutter upgrade a better shutter and less likely to fail or both shutter are of equal quality and free of defect and just offer different options to the M8 user ?
No, the shutter upgrade is not necessarily better, it just offers different options to the user.
4) Do you recommended upgrading the shutter for the sole reason that the shutter upgrade is a more robust and refined shutter and less likely to fail ?
No, it would be up to you.
5) Is there a warranty on the new shutter, if so how long and what is actually covered under the warranty ?
Yes, there is a one (1) year warranty on the billable repairs from Leica Camera.
6)What is actually done to the camera while being repaired ? Full CLA ... camera being completely cleaned and checked out ?
The work will contain adjustment of rangefinder, focus, light meter and shutter speed.
7) Can I have a Black Dot in place of the red one ? .... just kidding ,well not really ; )
No, we do not have any black dots, our logo is the red dot.
The cost of the repair $650.00 (original shutter)
Shutter count was under 5000 before the shutter buckled .
The camera is now back in use and I could not be happier ... good luck with your repair