raid
Dad Photographer
Is the CQ lens hood somehow better built thna the one by HeavyStar or SW?
Thanks for tips, Ari. I hope that you are enjoying using the Nikkor lens. One day, I will get such a lens again.
Never ever use any square or rectangular lens hood with a vintage Sonnar : the lens is not rectilinear guided when you focus, and the front element rotates. A square or rectangular hood would have its flat sides getting into the lens field of view every quarter of lens element turn.I wonder if the square 42mm clamp-on shade for old Mamiya TLR would work too?
::Ari
Never ever use any square or rectangular lens hood with a vintage Sonnar : the lens is not rectilinear guided when you focus, and the front element rotates. A square or rectangular hood would have its flat sides getting into the lens field of view every quarter of lens element turn.
So, conic (normal or tilted, whatever works) or cylindric shaped hoods only with that lens (and any other similar).
Excellent quality (vintage or recent generic) 40.5mm screw-in hoods are very easy to get, no needs to make the deal more complicated by wanting to use a 42mm push-on or clamp-on hood there IMO.
My (lost) lens hood was squarish, and I have never experienced any vignetting with it on the CZJ 5cm 1.5 or 5cm 2.0 or the J-3 or J-8.
Hmm, but in principle Highway 61 is right. If the square hood never intruded on your FOV, it means it wasn't doing the optimum shielding. For a given lens with rotating front, a round hood shields tighter before you see vignetting than a square one.
So it's not rotating, 'course.My CZJ lens is fitted inside a J-3 barrel by Brian Sweeney.
I haven't tried it (I will when I get home tonight), but I suspect that a vintage Canon RF hood with a 42mm adapter would fit.
In that case get a cheap 40.5mm filter, remove the glass from it, screw the bare filter ring firmly and once for all onto your Sonnupiter front threads, and then you're done for using any type of fully versatile push-on or clamp-on hood you might want to.