letters to a young photographer - the meaning of photography

caila77

Well-known
Local time
9:54 PM
Joined
Nov 1, 2005
Messages
485
Location
Italy
In recent years, it's rare for a podcast to catch my attention, but I have to say that this one, which starts from the idea of art and poetry and extends the same concept to photography, found me completely in agreement. It's in Italian, but with the automatic subtitles you can understand quite well.
the author of the video is inspired by the reflections contained in "Letters to a Young Poet" by Rainer Maria Rilke, that is a collection of letters that emerged from an exchange between an aspiring poet searching for himself in his works and looking to Rilke, an already established author, as someone who may hold potential answers to his uncertainties. This is Letters to a Young Poet: a collection of advice that serves as a beacon for all young artists groping in the dark. A small booklet to keep on the bedside table and reread in darker moments. Letters to a Young Poet leaves the reader plenty of room for careful self-reflection. It strikes the chords of sensitivity, emotion, and empathy, thus becoming a true emergency manual for wandering souls who lose their way.
What does it really mean to discover oneself? What defines us as people? We often understand the concept of self-discovery only in terms of identity. But can identity also be defined and consolidated by what we like to do? Without a doubt, Rilke's work answers this series of questions. Below is an excerpt from Letters to a Young Poet:

"No one can give you advice or help, no one. Go into yourself, find out why you need to write: examine whether it comes from the depths of your heart. Confess to yourself: would you die if you were forbidden to write? First of all, ask yourself in the quietest hour of the night: 'Am I really compelled to write? Dig deep within yourself for the deepest answer. If this answer is affirmative, if you can face such a serious question with a strong and simple ‘I must’, then build your life according to this necessity. Your life, even in its most indifferent, most empty hour, must become a sign and witness of such an impulse."

Art helps us discover beauty, nature, people, the world, ourselves. In his answers to Kappos' existential questions, Rilke teaches us that the answers to our questions lie only within ourselves. We must be courageous and learn to listen to the voice within us, which, at the right moment, will know what to tell us.

It is our passions that make us different
 
Last edited:
The idea of
'letters written to..." was a popular literary device in the early to mid 20th century, but it's nowadays quite a quaint notion.

It has been my experience in the past that young photographers don't read letters or even books. But they do go out and take photographs, which is as it should be.

This now written (tongue in cheek I must say), the OP has given us an interesting and thought-provoking post. Especially the last sentence. Thank you from me for posting.
 
Pigheadedness, stubbornness, stupidity, arrogance, just plain disagreeableness, some or all are the reasons I like to see others' work but none of them really inspire with the possible exception of Vivian Meier. HCB pretty much leaves me cold other than a few of his shots. But at the end up I shoot what pleases me regardless of how fuzzy my thinking, skewed my aesthetics or just plain stupidity influence me.

So I am with Rilke whose prose I have enjoyed so much. I can learn from others but to imitate them, I think, would be a mistake.
 
There is a painter on Instagram, Edward Povey, giving short aphoristic exhortations to young artists. Next month he convenes a painting retreat now booked out. He will take the artists from a bare canvas to a finished painting. He says they will be cured of copying, and chasing perfection. They will refine what is within and only that will produce a painting of worth.

Of course young aspirants need mentors, inspiring ideas and even instruction. But some with genius have the fire within already well lit and seem to need none of this. In life and art for many of us, paring down what we are exposed to, what we're commanded to do, and also induced to do out of competition, to what is uniquely ours and ours alone is like the return to childhood. To know of this development is already to strengthen our convictions and legitimate our interests and save us from worthless imitation.
 
In recent years, it's rare for a podcast to catch my attention, but I have to say that this one, which starts from the idea of art and poetry and extends the same concept to photography, found me completely in agreement. It's in Italian, but with the automatic subtitles you can understand quite well.
...

Could you post a link to the podcast that you're referring to?

G
 
letters to a young photographer - the meaning of photography

If your photography is unpopular you might be on to something good.

If you change your vision or your style to please others, you might be on to something bad.

Don’t get caught up in the color vs black & white, film vs digital, anything vs anything bull shit. Just do what works for you.

There’s nothing wrong with street photography, bokeh, or any of the other things people say are pointless, or passé.

Be creative, experiment, be serious and also have fun.

All the best,
Mike
 
letters to a young photographer - the meaning of photography

If your photography is unpopular you might be on to something good.

If you change your vision or your style to please others, you might be on to something bad.

Don’t get caught up in the color vs black & white, film vs digital, anything vs anything bull shit. Just do what works for you.

There’s nothing wrong with street photography, bokeh, or any of the other things people say are pointless, or passé.

Be creative, experiment, be serious and also have fun.

All the best,
Mike
All of the above! But I would add: be grounded in your culture. Understand the history of art and visual communications. People have been making images in rectangles for a long, long, time, and the history of photography is grounded in that tradition. And knowing the traditions and history can save you from re-inventing the wheel.
 
Different does not equal good. Unpopularity may be for a good reason. It can be a mistake to confuse crap with genius. We are not all closet Van Goghs. Let's get a grip.
 
Back
Top Bottom