Larry Cloetta
Veteran
Even the rangefinder patch in the Nikon S3 2000 I examined was low contrast. That's not a 50 year old camera. Maybe that's why there are more than a few threads on this site that have discussed how to improve the contrast on those cameras. And old SP's are known to have a faint secondary image. The one S2 I owned was pretty low contrast too, and that was after cleaning. And this is the same issue that the original poster apparently faced.
FWIW, the rf on the nice S3 2000 I owned was not as contrasty as the rf on my ancient S2 or SP. Others have noted this in the past regarding S3s of any vintage. Not saying that is everywhere and always the case, but was noticeable with my samples, and a laborious google search will second this (though a google search will validate anything one wants to believe.)
Even then, it never presented any difficulty in quick focusing. FWIW.