I think asking if state auto insurance/financial responsibility laws have been challenged is relevant because they represent a government mandate. It isn't relevant that no one is forced to drive. if you do drive, you are forced to buy insurance or post a bond.
Then it is not a mandate. You do not have to drive. Period. There is no mandate.
I think it is disingenuous to insist that the issue of single payer is a diversion. It isn't. A lot of people want single payer, but also want at least some reform if we can't, now, get single payer. People die because our health system is broken. A bill that patches it is better than nothing.
[Emphasis mine above]
No, sir, it is not. The patches that are being proposed make a bad situation worse - especially for me. That's that typical argument that I hear so much of;
"well, even if it is not perfect, we have to do something!" No, we do not have to 'do something' when 'something' is driving off a cliff. If we do not have a good answer to the problem, the best thing we can do is NOTHING.
Doing 'something' for the sake of 'doing something' is feel-good, populist, wrong-headed, and ultimately evil by neglect. Either do something real, something constructive, or leave things alone. If we lack the national will to tear down and completely revamp the current system, then stop breaking it more to fix nothing and take more money out of the paychecks of working Americans to do it. These bills are not just bad, they're the worst things ever. They cost nearly a trillion dollars and they trash the Constitution.
i understand you are angered about the prospect of mandated insurance. I'm not angered, no more than I am angered about mandated Social Security insurance payments.
Again, no one has to pay into social security if they earn no income. NOT A MANDATE.
You seem unclear on what a mandate actually is.
If these bills pass, we have to buy health insurance. Period. In practical terms, one may have to work, one may have to drive, but it still remains a choice. Buying or not buying health insurance will no longer be a choice. Stop pretending that it's no big deal, that it's done all the time. It is a very big deal, and no, it has never been done before in the USA. It's unconstitutional and wrong.