Robin Harrison
aka Harrison Cronbi
Nick Turpin, of In-Public fame (and, as I once saw him described, ‘the Simon Cowell of modern street photography’) has an interesting crowd-sourced project/experiment/gallery on the go. Called ‘The Best Street Photograph Ever’, it allows the upload and rating of street photographs, and the highly rated ones bubble to the top.
Check it out: http://www.sevensevennine.com/?page_id=2580
(also blogged via http://www.cronbi.com/2011/08/12/street-photography-is/)
It's not a perfect system, but the ranking seems pretty sound - the photos on page 1 are all exceptional, whilst the photos on pages 4 and 5 are more average.
Frank fan? Wild on Winogrand? Mad for Meyerowitz? Partial to Parr? (I'll stop now). Time to vote.
Check it out: http://www.sevensevennine.com/?page_id=2580
(also blogged via http://www.cronbi.com/2011/08/12/street-photography-is/)
It's not a perfect system, but the ranking seems pretty sound - the photos on page 1 are all exceptional, whilst the photos on pages 4 and 5 are more average.
Frank fan? Wild on Winogrand? Mad for Meyerowitz? Partial to Parr? (I'll stop now). Time to vote.
andredossantos
Well-known
Just curious, why is he considered the "Simon Cowell" of street photography? Thanks for the link, btw, interesting concept.
paulfish4570
Veteran
thanks for the link. quite interesting - and seductive.
illuminati_02
Established
Wow. Some great work posted there. Thanks for the link.
Robin Harrison
aka Harrison Cronbi
Well I think it's because he plucks street photographers from relative obscurity, or at least isolation, and brings them to a wider audience via his In-Public collective. But maybe it's not the strongest analogy!
zupstermix
Established
Thanks for sharing this!
andredossantos
Well-known
Oh, that's pretty cool. Im just glad it's not that he mercilessly insults people publically in a sadistic fashion!
Last edited:
kzphoto
Well-known
Neare
Well-known
Do people here not like Simon Cowell? I think he is such a great personality and a genuinely really nice guy.
dave lackey
Veteran
So, on the first page...nothing much worthwhile since 1980's? Curious.
semilog
curmudgeonly optimist
Yeah, mob rule is a useful method for "rating" street photography. What an incredibly depressing and awful thing that site is.
daninjc
Well-known
Wow, quite a harsh statement. Can you elaborate on that? Just curious.
I'm not a big fan of 'mob rule' in general as it tends to flatten out outliers - which often I find more stimulating.
Yet as an exercise for sampling the taste of a large community I find it quite interesting. And the pictures selected (anyone can upload any picture they want) are very good.
I'm not a big fan of 'mob rule' in general as it tends to flatten out outliers - which often I find more stimulating.
Yet as an exercise for sampling the taste of a large community I find it quite interesting. And the pictures selected (anyone can upload any picture they want) are very good.
semilog
curmudgeonly optimist
Yes, I can elaborate. The "star" system for ranking items is suitable for comparing toaster ovens at Amazon.com, not for comparing some of the most important, complex, and moving art of the last hundred years. It makes my skin crawl.
daninjc
Well-known
R.MacDonald
Established
No Bruce Gilden? You gotta be kidding me!
gns
Well-known
Last edited:
semilog
curmudgeonly optimist
Sure, but there's little whimsy there. Compare:
http://blakeandrews.blogspot.com/2011/03/sweet-sixteen.html
http://blakeandrews.blogspot.com/2011/03/sweet-sixteen.html
johannielscom
Snorting silver salts
Actually, I did. But, there never are more than five pages displayed and my shots never had a chance to get any rating before being pushed back into oblivion.
I'd say the idea is nice but in practise it's moot.
gns
Well-known
Agreed. That poll, while being basically the same thing, is at least packaged in a way that makes it clearly just a goof. Still, not much to get upset over in the first example.
(I think those two are both involved in the same site promoting modern "Street Photographers".)
migtex
Don't eXchange Freedom!
in the mean time take a look at Yanidel 80 weeks around the World... www.yanidel.net