gverdon
Member
robklurfield
eclipse
Gerald, that's a great image in every way. Thanks for sharing. Hope you'll post more of these.
Spyro
Well-known
Nice
10 char
10 char
will-i_am
Well-known
nice indeed
gverdon
Member
Thanks, guys.
Yes, I'll post more. ;-)
Cheers,
Gérald
Yes, I'll post more. ;-)
Cheers,
Gérald
peepete77
Established
Wow, this is AMAZING!! Such details and dynamics...wow....
aldobonnard
Well-known
sorry but what is the point in your photo ?
dfoo
Well-known
Great shot. Ignore the above critic.
craygc
Well-known
Yep ...very nice 
SimonSawSunlight
Simon Fabel
I'm waiting for the 'click' as well and would like to read/hear more about the photograph.
it is technically very good though.
it is technically very good though.
robert blu
quiet photographer
I like this picture because it could be the beginning of a story, a girl and her reflection using a mobile phone, policemen with antipollution mask coming...
robert
robert
Kozhe
Well-known
filmfan
Well-known
Nice, but it needs a few more images to go with it I believe. It's a good shot, but not exactly communicative enough to stand alone.
Excellent tonality and forms, but content is lacking. These are the two aspects of an image and I would say you aced the former. Whenever words are needed to explain an image, then the image does not speak for itself.
Excellent tonality and forms, but content is lacking. These are the two aspects of an image and I would say you aced the former. Whenever words are needed to explain an image, then the image does not speak for itself.
Last edited:
gb hill
Veteran
This is a good photo. You guys who don't seem to get it aren't looking deep enough. The reflections of both the girl & the police officer are very strong & the fact that all the faces are hidden or turned away from the camera adds mystery to the whole frame.
ramosa
B&W
just the woman and reflection=very good.
add in the police=excellent!
add in the police=excellent!
menos
Veteran
I didn't write, how much I like that shot Gérald!
Especially the detail in the girl's clothes and the careful framing with image and mirror image is great!
Especially the detail in the girl's clothes and the careful framing with image and mirror image is great!
gverdon
Member
Thank you and sorry.
Thank you and sorry.
Wow, sorry guys, I didn't take a look at this thread for a while.
Thank you for your comments and critics.
I can perfectly understand who is arguing that he missed the point of such a photograph; that's very personal and subjective, It works or it does not. And I have no problem with that.
It is always possible to see more on http://www.flickr.com/photos/geraldverdon/sets/72157624804282313/
in order to try to see the a "bigger picture", but I certainly won't write more about this specific image.
Again, thank you very much. All your comments appreciated.
Thank you and sorry.
Wow, sorry guys, I didn't take a look at this thread for a while.
Thank you for your comments and critics.
I can perfectly understand who is arguing that he missed the point of such a photograph; that's very personal and subjective, It works or it does not. And I have no problem with that.
It is always possible to see more on http://www.flickr.com/photos/geraldverdon/sets/72157624804282313/
in order to try to see the a "bigger picture", but I certainly won't write more about this specific image.
Again, thank you very much. All your comments appreciated.