trade critiques?

[back alley]

who is interested in trading critiques?
one on one
you show me yours and i'll show you mine

not necessarily you & me specifically but you and someone else

just add your name here and as the list grows, pick someone and ask them if they would like to critique a photo of yours in trade for you doing the same for them.
agree to invest some serious and quality time...to put it in writing...include both positive and negative comments and suggestions for improvment.
you can keep it private or do it in public...just come back here and make comment on the experience so we know if my idea is working or not...

i may have to patent it...lol.

 

[back alley]

the list...


joe aka back alley

 

[Sparrow]

the list...


joe aka back alley

... go on then ... sparrow alias Stewart McBride

1. joe aka back alley
2. sparrow alias Stewart McBride

 

[Godfrey]

Godfrey aka Godfrey ...

 

[mfunnell]

I'll be in it. The list so far:

1. joe aka back alley
2. sparrow alias Stewart McBride
3. Godfery aka Godfery
4. Mike aka mfunnell

...Mike

 

[FrankS]

The list so far:

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfery aka Godfery
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS

 

[back alley]

fairly underwhelming turnout…but you 4 are greatly appreciated!

maybe if i had made it about gear...

 

[michaelwj]

fairly underwhelming turnout…but you 4 are greatly appreciated!

maybe if i had made it about gear...

I'm in

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfery aka Godfery
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj

Michael

 

[Godfrey]

I'm in

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfery aka Godfery
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj

Michael

um, "Godfrey aka Godfrey" ...

G

 

[lynnb]

I'll play

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfrey aka Godfrey
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj
Lynn aka lynnb

 

[mfunnell]

um, "Godfrey aka Godfrey" ...

G

...Mike

P.S. I blame the Red Infuriator (Saltram's, I think)

 

[lynnb]

coincidentally, I just came across this article on critiquing, written by Alain Briot over on L-L

 

[Sparrow]

coincidentally, I just came across this article on critiquing, written by Alain Briot over on L-L

... in a concise 23 bullet points eh?

 

[Bike Tourist]

I'm off the list. Too much going on to give this the attention it deserves. Best wishes to all!

Well, I should warn you, I'm heavily invested in each of my images. If anyone says the slightest bad thing about one I fly into a rage culminating in following them to where they live. You know, just like the old camera club days. Ha, ha.

I'll play. Tell me what to do next.

Dick Thornton aka Bike Tourist

 

[Villanova]

Count me in!

 

[Lauffray]

I'm in


joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfrey aka Godfrey
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj
Lynn aka lynnb
Dick Thornton aka Bike Tourist
Villanova
Jerome aka Lauffray

 

[hexiplex]

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfrey aka Godfrey
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj
Lynn aka lynnb
Dick Thornton aka Bike Tourist
Villanova
Jerome aka Lauffray
Morgan aka hexiplex

Count me in.

 

[Trooper]

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfrey aka Godfrey
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj
Lynn aka lynnb
Dick Thornton aka Bike Tourist
Villanova
Jerome aka Lauffray
Morgan aka hexiplex
Trooper

I added my name.

 

[tarullifoto]

joe aka back alley
sparrow alias Stewart McBride
Godfrey aka Godfrey
Mike aka mfunnell
FrankS aka FrankS
Michael aka michaelwj
Lynn aka lynnb
Dick Thornton aka Bike Tourist
Villanova
Jerome aka Lauffray
Morgan aka hexiplex
Trooper

Count me in.

I'm in as well.

- Franco

 

[back alley]

this is looking good...