gzisis69
Established
Hello to the forum. First of all thank you for the help with the 35mm lens, i decided to invest my money on a scanner instead of a lens cause mine was also not so bad after i gave the camera a good cleaning. I now want to ask you something else. My girlfriend has her birthday in 3 weeks and i decided to gift her a nikon f100. My question now is which 50mm to get. I think she will enjoy more an af lens. The options are from the old ones 50 1.8/1.4 af-d and the new ones 50 1.8/1.4g. Which one would you choose ?
I prefer AFD as they can be used with my other cameras like F2 as they have aperture rings.
olakiril
Well-known
I was very surprised by the 50 1.8 af-d. Very fast, very good performance, tiny and very very cheap.
I had the 50/1.4G as well but even though it had a pleasing character is much larger, slow and more expensive and thus I would recommend the 50/1.8G if you want something better than the af-d 1.8.
The 50/1.4Af-D comes dead last. I never liked the output of that lens but maybe I have seen bad examples.
I had the 50/1.4G as well but even though it had a pleasing character is much larger, slow and more expensive and thus I would recommend the 50/1.8G if you want something better than the af-d 1.8.
The 50/1.4Af-D comes dead last. I never liked the output of that lens but maybe I have seen bad examples.
Austintatious
Well-known
Hard to beat the "nifty fifty" AF Nikkor 50mm F1.8 D
Phil_F_NM
Camera hacker
Perhaps just offer her the option of choosing a lens and you purchasing it for her.
Phil Forrest
Phil Forrest
aperture64
Shoot Film
I have the 50mm 1.8 and 1.4 AF-D. The 1.4 is better built and sharper, especially wide open. I prefer it over the G version because the F100 has custom settings and you can set it to use the aperture ring on the lens instead of the wheel on the camera body.
I have the original 50/1.4 AF-Nikkor, use it on my Nikon Df these days. Bought it for my Nikon N8008. 30+ years later- no problems. It's a good performer, great for low-light on the Df.
Archlich
Well-known
The 50/1.8G is the most sharp of the bunch. And light. And focuses fast and silently (the SWM motor works well on the F100). And reasonably well built, on par with the 50/1.4G which costs 3 times as much, unlike the 50/1.8D.
james.liam
Well-known
Why just a prime? The old 17-35/2.8 AFD is bigger but broadens the photographic possibilities. Great lens on film.