35/2 Summicron-M IV - Canada vs. Germany

dpetrzelka

dpetrzelka

Well-known
Local time
6:12 AM
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
223
Is there a difference optically/mechanically between the German and Canadian IV (fourth) version 35/2 Summicron-M?

Was one produced in significantly fewer numbers?
 
The German one was made by elves in the Black Forest using a secret ritual which makes the lens much sharper.

Otherwise they are identical.
 
dpetrzelka said:
Is there a difference optically/mechanically between the German and Canadian IV (fourth) version 35/2 Summicron-M?
Click to expand...
They shouldn't be. I don't have this lens but the Canadian-made Leica lenses I've used have all been excellent.
 
There is no difference between Canadian & German in quality. For collectibility German runs higher in price. Condition is the main consideration in price.
 
I had no concerns about quality differences- more a question of if they are the same optical formula, and is the unser interface the same -, tabbed, concave tab, same non-circular apature ring.

Thanks to all for the quick replys!
 
M. Valdemar said:
The German one was made by elves in the Black Forest using a secret ritual which makes the lens much sharper.

Otherwise they are identical.
Click to expand...

Apparently, they are the Silmarillions.
 
ferider said:
The German ones were designed in Canada by a Canadian :)
Click to expand...

From what I have read the 35mm Summicrons up to version IV were designed by Dr. Walter Mandler while working at ELCAN in Midland Ontario. I would think that the ones manufactured in Germany were the same optically and may have even been assembled from parts brought in from Canada. Dr. Walter Mandler and other key staff came to Canada from Germany to set up ELCAN. I wonder if he ever took out Canadian Citizenship? Sure would make me proud if he did considering his stature as a lens designer. I would also think that mechanical quality is the same aside from the fact that we do not have the benefit of the Black Forest elves here.

Bob
 
Nikon Bob said:
Dr. Walter Mandler and other key staff came to Canada from Germany to set up ELCAN. I wonder if he ever took out Canadian Citizenship?
Click to expand...

Yes, he did, Bob. Most of the modern Leitz lenses are his/his staff's
creation, including the Noctilux.

Best,

Roland.
 
The Canadian made examples are better.

How's that for starting a myth on Al Gore's internet?

I doubt that matters to the film anyway.
 
Nikon Bob said:
From what I have read the 35mm Summicrons up to version IV were designed by Dr. Walter Mandler while working at ELCAN in Midland Ontario. I would think that the ones manufactured in Germany were the same optically and may have even been assembled from parts brought in from Canada. Dr. Walter Mandler and other key staff came to Canada from Germany to set up ELCAN. I wonder if he ever took out Canadian Citizenship? Sure would make me proud if he did considering his stature as a lens designer. I would also think that mechanical quality is the same aside from the fact that we do not have the benefit of the Black Forest elves here.

Bob
Click to expand...

According to the wikipedia, Mandler did become a Canadian citizen.
he died in Midland in 2005.
 
venchka said:
The Canadian made examples are better.

How's that for starting a myth on Al Gore's internet?

I doubt that matters to the film anyway.
Click to expand...

If you are referring to the ones before Chernobly, yes, the cleaner air in Canada produced better lenses. But post Chernobly, the radioactivity in the glass seems to induce a property very akin to using lead.

I have to check my old measurements. It will take quite a while to look up though. :D
 
The radioactivity pre-flashes (fogs) the film, raising the exposure in the shadows to produce better shadow detail. ;)
 
Bump this topic

According to Gus Lazzari in this thread, the Canadian made one does have some plastic parts inside. Does anyone know what happen with the German made one?

I myself find my 35/2 IV German is good and solid enough for me but since many folks keep saying that the 35/2 III has better build (I used to have it but sold recently) that makes me feel a bit regretful.
 
Last edited:
Difference between Made in Canada and Made in German?

The ones made in Canada are cheaper on the second hand market. What a steal IMHO lol.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom