The left one looks to be a kind of v1 collapsible design. You can find it in batches 28 - 30 all from 1935. Those batches are shared between the nickel black ring round Sonnar 5cm F2, the later v2 collapsible design, some Contaflex Sonnar 5cm F2 and this v1 collapsible design. One has to admit that the Sonnar 5cm F2 production spawns even more designs and production run inconsistencies as the Sonnar 5cm F1.5 production.
The right one is pretty rare as you already stated. I have seen 2 in one year. With yours I have seen 3. Edit: I recognized your posting in the other thread with 24 / 55 serial numbers of this lens design. Looks like this all chrome rigid design was a common design before the full switch to the collapsible designs. The barrel looks similar to the Sonnar 5cm F1.5 all chrome one that was produced from May 1935 until 1940. Makes sense that they switched to this design for a short period of time.
Here are 2 findings from Ebay.
1.659.167
This single one comes from a batch of Sonnar 5cm F2 from March 1935 that contains nickel black ring round Sonnar 5cm F2 and Contaflex Sonnar 5cm F2.
1.866.371
Another single lens from a batch of Sonnar 5cm F2 from May 1935 that contains v2 collapsible F2 Sonnars and Contaflex Sonnar 5cm F2.