redisburning
Well-known
never evaluate a lens on someone else's scanning, unless you know them personally.
I have a bit of skill scanning myself and I still evaluate on the negative with a loupe. Maybe if I had a properly high end scanner like a LS-9000 or an Imacon I would use scans, but definitely not my little Minolta (which I like well enough for what I paid for it).
let me show you some examples of how scanning can vary:
bad drugstore:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
decent drugstore:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
some Boston lab:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
ncps (medium format)

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my scanner, E6

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my scanner, Portra 400

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my epson, medium format (sorry no color to show)

butters by redisburning, on Flickr
really scanning makes more difference than the lens when youre dealing with nice glass.
I have a bit of skill scanning myself and I still evaluate on the negative with a loupe. Maybe if I had a properly high end scanner like a LS-9000 or an Imacon I would use scans, but definitely not my little Minolta (which I like well enough for what I paid for it).
let me show you some examples of how scanning can vary:
bad drugstore:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
decent drugstore:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
some Boston lab:

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
ncps (medium format)

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my scanner, E6

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my scanner, Portra 400

Untitled by redisburning, on Flickr
my epson, medium format (sorry no color to show)

butters by redisburning, on Flickr
really scanning makes more difference than the lens when youre dealing with nice glass.


