Death Squads and the Leicas

Each of you has shown sensitivity and concern, and this is by itself a moving and rewarding experience. I send my family photos regularly "home" to cheer up my mother more than anyone else,but also to bring new images of my daughters to my brother's daughters and my sister's sons. We have become an internet/telephone connected family. I will take more decisive steps to reunite regularly with my family.

I hope that such personal postings are not taken as a "what a drag posting" . I know that life is wonderful and it is there to be fully enjoyed. This was the reason for leaving Iraq when I did.

"Memphis": you are a responsible and brave person. I wish you and your brother the best.



Raid
 
raid said:
Each of you has shown sensitivity and concern, and this is by itself a moving and rewarding experience. I send my family photos regularly "home" to cheer up my mother more than anyone else,but also to bring new images of my daughters to my brother's daughters and my sister's sons. We have become an internet/telephone connected family. I will take more decisive steps to reunite regularly with my family.

I hope that such personal postings are not taken as a "what a drag posting" . I know that life is wonderful and it is there to be fully enjoyed. This was the reason for leaving Iraq when I did.

"Memphis": you are a responsible and brave person. I wish you and your brother the best.



Raid

I think you just answered your question, keep shooting Raid, keep shooting...
 
Another of those moments where I ask myself why we can't live in peace for a change.
I can only hope your family stays safe, sorry I can't be of any help.
 
Raid,
I can't really imagine what you're going through. I do think, however, that the fact that you have these kinds of doubts speaks volumes about your humanity. Too many people I know simply can't see beyond their own noses and seem to think "every thing is just fine". Which then lets them off the hook for not doing anything.
My prayers are with you and your family.
Rob
 
Raid: If you could get your family out of Iraq, you would. If you can't, then the best thing you can do is to bring some of your life to them. Photographs help do that. So does whatever moral support and material help you can get to them. I'm sure you are doing that already.

In the meantime, keeping yourself whole and emotionally healthy is important, too. Your photography helps with that, so don't feel that it's somehow wrong. If the situation were reversed and it was you who were back in Baghdad, would you want your relative in America to refrain from living fully? I suspect not--you would probably think, "at least *he* is doing well and is happy."

What you're feeling is very common. I heard the same kind of feelings expressed by my grandparents and their friends, who could not get their European family members out of Hitler's Europe. Wherever there are refugees, there are brothers, sisters, parents, aunts, uncles, cousins and dear friends who stayed behind. Everybody who got out feels guilty on behalf of those who didn't. "Why me? What did I do to deserve this, when so-and-so is still there?"

So you do what you can. And of course, you worry. But don't beat yourself up for not being Superman. The madness that is going on right now is bigger than any one of us. As much as we can hang on to being civilized and decent human beings, and as much as we can remind those in the places of madness that civility, decency, and kindness still exist, then we are still doing something--even if it seems not very much.

Be well, and may the madness end soon!
--Peter
 
Raid, I cannot imagine how life is in Iraq now: but I can understand your feelings about your family situation, and I want to offer all my sympathy.
Do not give up your hopes, otherwise you cannot help your family.
Mauro
 
For the life of me, I can't understand why the people of Iraq can't forget their regional and sectarian religious differances and live in peace, harmony and prosperity--especially when they are now free of that evil dictator and literally sitting on all that oil.
 
Raid, by pursuing your hobby here on this forum you are at the very least dispelling the media stereotype of Iraq and Iraqis, the news programs concentrate on just the victims and perpetrators of violence and the ordinary people get no voice, simply by making your normal posts a shared humanity is coming through that gives the deaths in Iraq a sharper focus, for me at any rate it gives them a human face.

I do hope we (the west) are doing the right thing, and in common with everyone I hope for the safety of you families, and a better future for the country.

Best wishes
 
I believe you have given your family much more hope than you can ever imagine, and that they can ever be thankful enough for. Love has a way of working miracles just where they are needed, and where men could never conceive of any possible good happening.
 
People like you give me hope that not all people are preferring to close their eyes. I got quite emotional when I posted my thread because my brother had just informed me about the Street of Death in Baghdad being very close to our home. It seems that "they" chose that street for dumping executed people. I am simply not as desensitized to killings as Iraqis now are.

It's never easy or wrong to share your feelings.

Raid
 
Stewart: Such events are not changed by people like us. I recall the Iraq-Iran War. Everything seemed so hopeless for several years, then one morning I woke up here to be surprised by the peace arrangements made overnight. Even Khomeini said that signing that peace arrangement was "like drinking poison". Maybe the same forces that arranged the Irq-Iran war and then the peace will finally decide that too many people have been killed and that there must be peace. Don't ask me who those forces are. I am just a university professor teaching statistics.

Raid
 
Raid,
Thanks for this thread. I'm glad (in a way) to see others that are faced with these dilemmas.

I have no such personal connections to Iraq as you do, but I've met many people and seen things on my travels that stick with me. I remember an Iraqi family that lived in northern Slovakia, refugees from Baghdad. There was such despair in them that I wondered (they did too) if they were really better off. Alone in a very different country, unable to do anything for their family back home except watch the news on satellite. And SLovakia has no immigrant tradition like the US has--so there was little hope of ever feeling at home again--or even integrating at the basic level.

This was in 2000. We had an easter meal together (they were orthodox Christians) that was wonderful. The joy on Roman's face when I brought eggplant I bought in Bratislava, the relish with which they prepared it. It was a wonderful time, but it was in the end more bitter than sweet. There was a lot of anger in them--at Saddam, at the US for its bombing. There was nothing I could do for them, or for the other refugees there--from Bosnia, Albania, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Sierra Leone.

I have never met sadder people in my life, and it was a real challenge.

Ultimately (I believe) life is somewhat random. Some are rewarded with lots of joy, others with unbelieveable strife. All we can do is what we have talent for and capacity (and situation) to do: try to apply our potential towards some idea of human progress--here, there, anywhere. And beauty has a place in that, and art.

Your search to reconcile your art and your agony is a noble one...you should neither give up the former, nor stifle the latter.

I hope the descent into madness stops soon, and better natures win out.
 
raid said:
I am originally from Baghdad (Iraq), and my family still lives there.
My wife and I get each day news from our families in Baghdad, and these news are typically along the line of keeping us abreast of the count of executed people thrown within 100m of our family homes.

I start thinking about myself and my role in this world. Am I being side tracked by my hobby? Is it fundamentally wrong that I am enjoying Leicas while my family hopes to stay alive each following day in Baghdad?

Maybe some of you are going through a similar soul search.

I wish I had the answer to my search.

Raid, there's no answer, and no reason for any guilt other than the reasons you "invent" for yourself.

I have family in law in poor situations. I have seen people in less than human conditions. I have no answers to remedy those circumstances and situations. All I can do is give some money to my family, donate money to orgs like Amnesty Int or Unicef, and try to keep my own wasting and squandering to a minimum. But it's still my life and I live it my way. Making myself unhappy and depressed isn't helping anyone, least of all those in dire straits. That said, of course I can't stop thinking about solutions I can enter into, or ways to remedy such situations. It's hard to realise how limited my impact is in this world.
 
raid,
my response has two components: one is to try to address what you are experiencing and to try to give you some reassurance and hope. the other is to share my thoughts on how each of us might respond to others in need whether we know them or not.

i don't know that any of my thoughts on your troubling introspection will be of any help or solace. i hope they will be.

by doing so, you are reflecting your love for your family in a very profound manner. it requires a good deal of inner strength and integrity to do so. you are showing the depth of that concern by looking inward and by loving and holding your family close to your heart. you are doing something positive in the face of all that cannot be done right now.

some thoughts on what i think can be done...
it seems there is little that can be done to stop the evil that affects our world. however, i think there is something each of us can do. each of us can reach out - like many have done on this thread - to someone in need of help.

thankfully there are many, many organizations that do make a positive difference in the world. they have the resources and experience to accomplish the endeavors they undertake.

on a person-to-person level, we can respond directly to the survivors of terrorism, insurrection, war, and other acts of violence. that response can be a letter to them, or a letter or hundreds of letters to major newspapers. it can be a peaceful gathering like a candle-light vigil, it can be reaching out person-to-person, a mass e-mail campaign to various media and talk-shows, a community relief effort, a phone bank campaign through your church, synagogue, temple, ashram, or mosque. it can also be through a social or business association. those are just a few ideas. thankfully there are more creative and affective people out there than myself. i have to fight a sometimes over-powering sense of helplessness and that there is little , if anything, i can do to make a difference in the world. there is always hope.

hope is the driving force that sustains my efforts. knowing there are other people who have the same belief reinforces me. if we don't have hope, tomorrow is just another day.

just by trying to help, we are making a difference. whatever that difference is, it is far better than allowing indifference to overpower us and numb our hearts.

throughout the history of the world, the will and the heart of the individual has settled vast wildernesses, overthrown corrupt governments, survived countless wars, natural disasters and everything else. there are many factors that contributed to those sucesses. i believe the primary one is hope. people committed to a course of action is another one.

alright, off of my soapbox. thanks to all that took their time to wade through this ramble of mine. i hope what i have shared here will be of some help to someone.
_____________________________________

smile, breathe, relax and enjoy
_____________________________________

hasta la vista, voyez-vous plus tard, daskorava,fino al prossimo tempo, auf wiedersehen, vedali piu sucessivamente, la revedere, sai jen, and ... later y’all !!

kenneth lockerman
NEVER FORGET BESLAN
www.neverforgetbeslan.com
www.neverforgetbeslan.org (under construction)
kenneth@neverforgetbeslan.com

"...patience and shuffle the cards" miguel cervantes "nothing can be learned" herman hesse
"everybody knows everything" jack kerouac
"some memories are realities and better than anything" willa cather
" doo-wacka doo, wacka doo" roger miller
"we have met the enemy and they is us !" walt kelly (pogo)
 
Last edited:
Raid,

You've touched on a subject here that many of us, in one form or another, have wrestled with. I've been helping my friend Suraj, who lives in a Maoist controlled section of Nepal, in small ways. But there is little I can do to lessen the threat of violence he faces.

If you could trade your Leica in and help your family, no doubt you would do so. As would I. Unfortunately that isn't how the world works.

My thoughts and best wishes are with your family, please keep us posted.

adam
 
Raid, you and your family have been in my thoughts since I read your post. I've waited a little before writing because I wanted to reflect on your question. I've wondered too if photography wasn't a "vanity," to use the very old word -- something vain, useless to practice, when there are urgent matters at hand. But two thoughts keep coming back to me.

The first thought is of a Zen master, the abbot of a temple I've visited, who is a practicing and very talented photographer, John Daido Loori. He was a student of Minor White, and like his teacher he has a tremendous ability to reveal patterns in nature that we would otherwise overlook. But I think I'm safe in saying that for him the photograph is not the only end. The process in itself can be a meditation, a way of stilling ourselves, connecting to the world, and thereby enabling ourselves to give our best to the world.

The other thought concerns rangefinder photography, which is such a different type of shooting. It struck me as I looked through some of Leica's promotional materials that every photograph they showed was of a person, or of a group of people. I wonder if this particular kind of photography has a special power to connect us to people? In that respect, I think, it can be anything but an avoidance of the world. It can be a way to connect all the more closely with it, and as such, a moral good.

I've gone on quite a bit, but I'll just echo the encouragement of everyone else here. I admire your taking these questions to heart, Raid. Sincere best wishes to you and your family.

-- Michael
 
Back
Top Bottom