Digital or Film? Post Yours Let's Guess

[lament]

I will guess both the man in the hat and the wall are digital.

Todd's two top images (without exif) are obviously oversharpened. If they're film, they're post-processed.
QUOTE]

cross processed, not post processed, over sharpened...not really.

They're visibly oversharpened; it might be flickr applying sharpening to resized photos.

 

[lament]

Some people came pretty close to guessing my photo, good job
It's actually a digital photo - cropped and perspective-corrected - of a film (chromogenic b&w) print. FWIW the crappy scanner I have gives a very similar result.

 

[jtzordon]

So far so good. I've seen all of the answers, so couldn't prove it, but I got 'em all except the girl with the guitar. That one was very tricky. Todd's second one was tricky as well; I guessed film and then second-guessed and second-guessed again! This is a blast.

....let's see if I have something...

 

[jtzordon]

Best I can do, for now.

 

[ibcrewin]

you got it! the top two are Velvia, cross processed...the last one is digital, if you looked at the exif you cheated

Todd

I didn't look. I was on the fence with the last one!

 

[ibcrewin]

Best I can do, for now.

I'm going to guess film on this one..For no other reason than the people at the bottom look like they are dressed in the 50's.

 

[lament]

Best I can do, for now.

I'm guessing film

 

[anaanda]

Is it live or Memorex? Is it film or digital? Post images that you think might fool us. Let us try to figure it out whether the source was film or digital. Guess and tell us why.

Here's mine:

Film or Digital?

Its very difficult to tell on screen but when you see a print its easy to tell film apart from digital...

 

[dmr]

I can't tell. I know some photos just "look digital" but for any given example I sure have a hard time telling. A couple years ago I had a hard time convincing a co-worker that one shot I took was film until I showed him the negative.

 

[shadowfox]

Best I can do, for now.

I'm guessing digital, overall a bit too sharp front to back (hallmark of a smaller sensor)

 

[shadowfox]

My turn:

easy.. no?

 

[350D_user]

Best I can do, for now.

Film. The contrast range is a bit beyond what digital will do.

My turn:

Digital, courtesy of blown highlights.

 

[350D_user]

This one should be easy...

 

[iml]

How about this.

Ian

 

[lament]

This one should be easy...
View attachment 45125

If that's digital, you have to teach me how you do that.

 

[iml]

And here's another.

Ian

 

[fishric]

Ok I'll play, try this,
Richard F.

 

[fishric]

And this,
Richard F.

 

[RayPA]

Best I can do, for now.

I think I've gotten one right! Follow your contrarian instincts when reading my guesses. For this one I'm saying digital. It just has that look.

.

 

[Kin Lau]

What's your guess?