Nokton48
Veteran
Hey Nokton48 I see you use the Freestyle one; I'm not totally certain that its exactly the same to the Kodak version; Kodak had the X factor (ha sorry) of the mercapto and as far as I know this still remains a secret and propriety of Kodak patents. The Ilford version is close as is the home-brew but in my experience the Kodak version has less grain and gets a wonderful creamy feel in the highlights when used repenished. I've noted the kodak suggestions regarding the mixing of replenisher in their recommended method but luckily I picked up many (15+) 1 gallon bags of real Microdot-X replenisher and as you know using 1/2 an ounce per roll one gallon can last a while!
Wow you were very lucky to get all that Microdol-X replenisher. 🙄
Do you find that the Microdol-X you use is holding up OK, I would imagine it's getting rather old at this point? Ilford Perceptol is similar to Microdol-X but I wouldn't be surprised if there are some chemical differences.
I do like the Legacy Mic-X, I just bought three more gallons to use in the future. But my three-year old gallon stock solution is still going strong. It's similar to Kodak Microdol-X but I pretty sure it's not exactly the same, as you say. But it does work very well for me.