Roger Hicks
Veteran
Dear David,Hi,
Yes, it was in Coe's book. I looked it up last night and ticked off another item on the loose ends list.
In many ways it was a good thing even though it was "wrong" as it kick started a lot, imo. A lot of pioneer's who got nowhere at the time were important for helping show the way to go and not go; although a lot only remember the winners and forget how much they relied on others' work.
Regards, David
I'd suggest that it was unreservedly a good thing: happy accidents arising from mistakes, misconceptions and adventures have, I am sure, contributed the vast majority of human progress.
And yes, the "winner takes all" mentality is awful. As witness -- to go back to artistic "theory" -- Sontag. Because her writing is tendentious, opaque and pseudo-intellectual, and because few can be bothered to read it, she is a "winner" in the "theory of photography" stakes. Everyone has heard of her, and so she serves as a place-holder for everything they haven't read but wish/pretend they have.
Cheers,
R.