Responding to your request Peter, and seeing so many varied images here in the thread:
I can't disagree with anything you've said here. For my part though, and with so many thread repositories on this site to post to, I read what Helen stated and try to keep to my sense of what that might be (tough to articulate but I think I get it 🙂 Helen's "boils down to shadow and light" stays with me) and I post accordingly. To a certain extent, my approach as relates to images I would post to this thread is more about reacting in the abstract to what is out there when I am walking with my camera. With "decisive moment" and your images nicely illustrate that thinking here, for me those kinds of images come from a different place. I say "for me" not in anyway suggesting those (i.e. yours above ^^^ here) do not fit here, to the contrary.
In sum then, I would say, and Alen's image above ^^ also case in point, we all have our own sense of which of our own images "belong" here in Final Essence.
David