Which Wide Angle for Zorki/FED?

[martinsmith99]

I already have a J12 but looking for something a bit wider.

I'm torn between a 28mm Orion 15 and a Russar 20mm. The Russar is twice the price, but 8mm wider.

Any experience with these lenses?

 

[CTAPbIU_XPEH_RUSSIA]

Orion-15 for example. I like Orion-15.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/68343288@N06/6629202247/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/68343288@N06/6629212917/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/68343288@N06/6629214715/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/68343288@N06/6629219809/

 

[tojeem]

Sorry, no experiences here, but they both seem to me like very slow lenses. What kind of photography are you hoping to do?

I've heard both lenses are good. Personally I prefer the Russar, based on what I've seen online, but the Orion seems more popular so it would probably be better choice from a repair/parts perspective. Plus it's cheaper so you could splash out on a decent viewfinder and still have money left over for film.

If it were me (and it probably will be when I get enough money!), I'd go with the Orion simply for practicality. I suppose it really comes down to those 8mm... can you afford to stand back to take shots, or won't the situation allow it?

Sorry I couldn't be much help.
Stephen