Phil,
I live at the “Gateway to the Hudson Highlands” and that geography means some hills are both long and steep. One steep hill is Hudson Avenue that leads from the Peekskill train station. It is a quarter mile in length to Washington Avenue which is the first main road that heads north and south. Just this section is brutal in a 20 inch gear because of the length and steepness.
I can ride it, but Hudson Avenue continues to climb another mile, although not as steeply. I see people walking their bikes up this 1/4 mile climb all the time.
Know I have a road bike already, a Ti Basso (rebranded Litespeed Classic).
Setting up a triple perhaps on the road bike with a 9-speed 11-34 would work but that also is fraught and not so EZ-PZ.
What is easer would be is set up the IBIS SS Avion with the 11-34T 9-speed with the 48/38/24 on the bike now. A 17.65 low and a 109.09 top gear with a 25 inch tire 1.25 wide. If I converted over to a Schwable Billy Bonkers a pump track specific tire with a gravel like thread for asphalt that has a full 2.1 inch width I get an 18.35 bailout gear; a 20.8 granny gear; and a reasonably tall 113.45 gear inch high gear.
To sum it up: a mountain bike even with a 2x11 suffers with a lack of high gears; a road bike lacks the low gears that would be practical where I live; and basically a triple would serve me well.
Kinda divine intervention how the SS Avion seems to be ideal for this conversion, or I could do this to the Newsboy.
I have my training loop which is an hour long. The Hudson Avenue climb from the train station is part of that loop. Doing the loop twice is brutal. Think high threshold of pain. I may not be fast like Mike the skinny hipster, but I know I am strong. This is a fast workout, but at times I’ll do a second loop to beat myself up. Know that heading south down Washington leads to the valley where my house is, so pretty much this is my cool down after maxing out my heart rate.
I will first max out the 2x11 on the Newsboy with an 48/32 up front. I have a long cage derailleur on that bike with a 45T max cap. The frame has a 1 3/8 derailleur hanger to promote a possible extension of the max cap. I have both 11-40T and 11-42T XT cassettes 11-speed stockpiled.
The triple with a 3x9 though looks better suited for what I need.
The Newsboy kinda resembles an English 3-speed with the leather saddle and a mustache bar. Mucho early vintage boutique parts, many not available anymore. Early Paul’s Moon Units that were big, Grafton brakes, Ti high rise stem… In other words it is like a bike museum.
Cal