Calzone
Gear Whore #1
Phil,
“Maggie” is in wait and see mode. She also likes the Specialized FX-6 which weighs 21 pounds and is full carbon.
My criticism of that bike is that while it has nice carbon wheels and has a reasonable low gear, it lacks on the top end for a high gear Say for motoring downhill.
Perhaps not a bad limitation. This is marketed as a “fitness” bike. Evidently Maggie fell for the marketing.
At this point also I think the Newsboy for me has proven to be a keeper as is, even though the 97.36 inch high gear is somewhat limiting on descents. I can go wider than the 1.8 width I currently use now and gain a taller profile to extend my top gear range.
So in a way both our top end gears will be limited and will be close to 100 gear inches which is fine on a rail-to-trails.
This is why I favor a 3x9 for more gears, wider range, and where overlaps are good, especially for long epic riding/touring.
Perhaps I too favor the FX-6 for Maggie because of the carbon wheel set and the light weight. The laws of physics become more pronounced in smaller people like Maggie and I who are lightweights.
Anyways now maybe I can be selfish with the 9-speed on the shelf to build out a bike for me.
Cal
“Maggie” is in wait and see mode. She also likes the Specialized FX-6 which weighs 21 pounds and is full carbon.
My criticism of that bike is that while it has nice carbon wheels and has a reasonable low gear, it lacks on the top end for a high gear Say for motoring downhill.
Perhaps not a bad limitation. This is marketed as a “fitness” bike. Evidently Maggie fell for the marketing.
At this point also I think the Newsboy for me has proven to be a keeper as is, even though the 97.36 inch high gear is somewhat limiting on descents. I can go wider than the 1.8 width I currently use now and gain a taller profile to extend my top gear range.
So in a way both our top end gears will be limited and will be close to 100 gear inches which is fine on a rail-to-trails.
This is why I favor a 3x9 for more gears, wider range, and where overlaps are good, especially for long epic riding/touring.
Perhaps I too favor the FX-6 for Maggie because of the carbon wheel set and the light weight. The laws of physics become more pronounced in smaller people like Maggie and I who are lightweights.
Anyways now maybe I can be selfish with the 9-speed on the shelf to build out a bike for me.
Cal